Cross Assault sexual harassment controversy overshadows on-screen combat

Default_picture
Wednesday, February 29, 2012

Pakozdi and Bakhtanians

 

“The sexual harassment is part of [the] culture. And if you remove that from the fighting game community, it’s not the fighting game community."

Those words came from the mouth of Street Fighter X Tekken tournament participant Aris Bakhtanians  on day five of Cross Assault, the Capcom sponsored reality show streamed on IGN. This absurd but telling statement came in response to a call for civility from Jared Rea, community manager of streaming host Twitch.tv.

Bakhtanians proceeded to equate an FGC (fighting game community) without sexual harassment to using a football in the NBA.

This display resulted from events beginning on day one of the tournament. Bakhtanians, captain of Team Tekken, spent a good thirteen minutes of the stream harassing lone female team member Miranda “Super__Yan” Pakozdi. The video below, from Destructoid, captures Pakozdi, surrounded by men, attempting to laugh off an unending stream of abuse until she can no longer endure it.

 

When Bakhtanians invades Pakozdi’s personal space near the end of the clip, she retreats from the room

 

Giant Bomb obtained a screen capture of tweets from Pakozdi (@Super__Yan) including one relating her distress at Capcom’s apparent apathy. This particular tweet longer appears on her feed. She has also suggested in her tweets that additional inappropriate behavior occurred off-stream.

On day six, after a clearly disinterested performance, Pakozdi forfeited. Tournament boss Matt Dahlgren of Capcom-Unity provided an on-screen apology shortly afterward. Pakozdi has since indicated via Twitter that Capcom handled the process appropriately while expressing concern as to how she's percieved. She also explained that she was not comfortable enough with the hostile atmosphere to return for the final round.

 

 

She has repeatedly and vehemently cited her initial agreement with Capcom not to entertain requests for interviews. Neither she nor Bakhtanians has responded to press requests for comment.

Predictably, the by-default-misogynistic echo chamber of certain parts of the FGC has generated some blowback for Pakozdi, essentially accusing her of “asking for it”:

 

 

Other parts of the community have decried Bakhtanians's actions. On her blog, Nonsense Machine, FGC member Emily Chow offers her support and relates her own experiences with the petrifying dicomfort of sexual harassment. She corroborates Pakozdi's stance that attemping to defuse anxiety with laughter does not imply consent to the offending behavior.

Unfortunately for all of us, none of this occurred in a vacuum. In the video game community at large, the FGC does not have a monopoly on casual misogyny. Just ask Jennifer Hepler. The issue keeps coming up because we have not laid it to rest and likely won’t for some time. The cultural momentum of insular communities ensures they change at a glacial pace.

That said, we’ll never see improvements without discussion. Miranda Pakozdi’s harrowing trial has certainly sparked one. Hopefully, it will gain a high enough profile to lead to something positive rather than getting the customary brush off.

For its part, Capcom has responded to all press inquiries with the following statement:

“The views and opinions expressed by cast members in the live internet program 'Cross Assault' do not reflect those of Capcom. As a company, Capcom believes that everyone should be treated with respect. This particular issue was brought to our attention and has been addressed. We sincerely apologize to anyone that was offended by any comments expressed during the show.”

 


 

Don't let this kind of disrespectful, childish nonsense remain the status quo. Keep the conversation going.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (16)
Default_picture
February 29, 2012

Man, I am just really disgusted. I am not a professional gamer, or have much interest in watching a lot of it so I have not really been exposed to this.

I had an idea that gamers had a tendancy to a be a bit more enlightened on the whole than a lot of other people--simply due to the friends I keep. I guess the friends I keep are (luckily) not the sort of cloistered and ignorant blowhards which apparantly exist in the fighting game commuity. They are overgrown children, except children usually develop a sense of self-knowing pretty rapidly.The most disturbing part was this guy's defense of his actions--utterly ignorant.

People who hide behind the (idiotic) defense of free speech, or "This is America! Arn't we in America? This is merrika!" frustrate me to no end. Yes, you can say what you want, but if you say things that are disgusting and repulsive and hateful enough to other people, they have the right to tell you to shut up or ostricise you if they choose. Yes, you can say what you want, you can publish a book of whatever you like, but other people have the right to shout louder than you about how wrong you are.

This guy also seems to hide behind cultural relativism, which is utter bullshit in itself. If stopping sexism would stop the fighting game community as we know it, than go nuts. We don't need a bunch of sheltered overgrown children spewing bile at one another.

Quick note: Not to say that the fighting game community is REALLY sexist, I don't know that. Not to say all fighting game fans are the scum of the earth--because I am one, a big one. I have almost every fighting game released on both PS2 and PS3. I just think it is unacceptable to give this bearded fu...gentleman in the videos a modicum of respect in society until he can learn to stifle his creepy hatred. Get him off the show. I never knew about it until this controversy (the controversial realization that the lovable nerds in our society have a hateful underbelly) happened, and although I have some interest in watching it I never will while this guy is still on it--and any others who think his brand of "culture" are worth paying attention to.

Default_picture
February 29, 2012

I can sympathize with your experience; having your illusions shattered about the relative intelligence of a group you identify with is jarring. I can't say I remember a time when I believed that about people who play games, though. Our experiences seem pretty divergent.

Bakhtanians doesn’t concern me as much as the fact that his behavior is a symptom of a much wider problem. A lot of the reporting I have seen has been about the culture of the FGC. While that follows naturally from the opening quote, I thought it was a pretty narrow perspective and tried to provide a wider context here.

Luckily, I came across Emily Chow's tumblr post just as I was looking for a supportive stance from within the FGC. Hers is the most relevant viewpoint I could have hoped for.

It seems like this conversation never gains any traction. It's disgusting and disheartening. I hope that's just pessimistic confirmation bias on my part.

Default_picture
February 29, 2012

I do think sexual harassment is part of the fighting game culture. I'm not defending sexual harassment. I'm saying the gaming community as a whole is pretty immature, almost to the point of being a parody of itself. That was disgusting.

Anyone who says Pakozdi brought it on herself is using the just-world fallacy, which pops up often whenever women are victims of sexual harassment or abuse.

Default_picture
February 29, 2012

Evidently sexual harrasment IS part of the fighting game community, but it should not be, and it should not be tolerated by the people inside the community or those outside of it. It is important to speak up, even if you think it will make you an outsider. Don't tolerate this idiocy.

People have the right to say what they want, and if you want to tell someone to shut their pie hole because they are a sexist child, you better exercise that right.

Default_picture
February 29, 2012

I'm not 100% sure if you're trying to argue with me or not, or even how you took my comment. Just to be clear, I completely agree with you. 

Dscn0568_-_copy
February 29, 2012

I fixed the video and Twitter issues.

The fighting-game tournaments I've been to in Orlando have been very welcoming and diverse. I hate how Aris and a few others have become the voice of the community on this matter since I've seen and heard others in support of Super Yan, but this is an issue for a reason. I feel really bad for her since she had to put up with this treatment for days to the point that she didn’t care about the competition anymore.

Default_picture
February 29, 2012

I appreciate the help.

Dscn0568_-_copy
February 29, 2012

No problem. If you're interested Aris did post this. http://www.twitlonger.com/show/g65iqn

Default_picture
February 29, 2012

Good link. I can't say I know how to react to that. He seems to apologize for defending his actions the way he did (day 5), but not the actions themselves (day 1).

If he ends up being genuine (which I'm admittedly skeptical of), that will be great. It would certainly be a step in the right direction.

Default_picture
February 29, 2012

Ugh. A friend posted a story on this from a different website. I tried hard not to watch the video. After seeing the first few minutes, I was really disgusted.

You might want to explain what FGC stands for, because you really confused me with that abbreviation.

Default_picture
February 29, 2012

I was also confused when I first ran into the FGC initialism. I had hoped it would be clear appearing shortly after the quote, but I guess not. I've edited the article.

Default_picture
February 29, 2012

Lol. Thanks. You don't want to mix FGC up with a certain Wikipedia definition.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FGC

Lolface
February 29, 2012

Hey...what do you have against the Family Groove Company?

Default_picture
February 29, 2012

Haha, sounds like Sly & The Family Stone.

That wasn't what I was referring to, but that FGC sure sounds pretty damned cool.

Default_picture
August 15, 2012

It was just brought to my attention that you covered this story back in February. Thank you for including my blog post in your article!

Default_picture
August 16, 2012

No problem, but I should be thanking you!

At the time, I had been practicing writing different kinds of game industry/culture articles. I wanted to write a feature article about something I felt strongly about and this happened to be in the news.

While I could have made my case independently, your first-hand experience makes for an authorative rebuttal to harassment apologists. Thanks again!

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.