Games are so gay (and that's a good thing)

Rm_headshot
Tuesday, April 10, 2012

"Will the makers of Star Wars video games create Darth VaPaula, a (mock) transgender version
of Darth Vader/RuPaul for kids to choose as their action character?"

That's just part of the funniest protest letter I've ever read, as drafted a month ago by the Florida Family Association. Their mission statement: to "educate people on what they can do to defend, protect, and promote traditional, biblical values." So I doubt they're actually advocating for the inclusion of Darth VaPaula as a character option in Star Wars: The Old Republic even though their letter often reads that way.

Star Wars: The Old Republic
Two grown men rubbing their giant, glowing phalluses together. Yep, totally straight.

They're also late to the party. The Family Research Council, a far bigger Christian advocacy group, jumped on developer BioWare's plan to patch gay/lesbian/bi/transgendered options into The Old Republic way back in January, and they've been sending hate mail to publisher Electronic Arts ever since. As FRC President Tony Perkins put it, "In a new Star Wars game, the biggest threat to the empire may be homosexual activists!"

Let's momentarily ignore that Perkins cast his homosexual activists in the heroic Rebel Alliance role and straight-up nail this issue: Games need more gender-bending sexual experimentation, not less. In fact, that's been the medium's historical role as well.

 

First of all, let's acknowledge that, while you'll find plenty of perfectly honest Christians fragging away on their platform of choice, neither the FFA nor the FRC are gamers or represent gamers. Mainly, they're in the boycott-for-publicity business. Tough to do if you don't actually participate in the game itself or buy the company's products. Instead, they want to whip up outrage and fear around the idea of homosexuals, by their very presence, inflicting a gay social agenda on other innocent people.

I wonder if anyone's told them that a lot of men buying these games voluntarily create and play as female characters. Is that what they mean by transgendered?

When you play a video game, you assume a role. Sometimes it's defined, like Gears of War's Marcus Fenix or Metal Gear Solid's Solid Snake. Other times, the developer hands you a blank slate and lets you fill in the blanks. We create a character, and often we impose our personality, our feelings, on that avatar to fully immerse in the epic struggle de jour. If those feelings tend towards someone of your own gender, the game that doesn't include those options rings false. A better game lets you imprint yourself completely to complete the fantasy.


That's not it. That's not it. Lower. Ow!

Sometimes that fantasy means stepping away from yourself instead. "FemShep," the female version of Mass Effect's Commander Shepard, has such a strong following that Mass Effect 3 features a reversible cover to feature both male and female heroes. You can quite literally swing both ways and, as FemShep, pursue relationships with male or female characters. A lot of players do. And nobody thinks anything about it.

When gamers first beat Metroid and found out -- surprise! -- they'd played as a woman the whole time, society didn't cave in. Overt sexuality aside, nobody's ever complained about inhabiting Lara Croft, Jill Valentine, Joanna Dark, or Bayonetta, to name a few. I'm willing to bet few men ever felt funny about being a woman for a while -- female gamers, certainly, take on male roles as a matter of rote -- and I highly doubt a video game has altered too many sexual orientations. But yeah, I'll say fantasy still plays a part here. We spend our game time being someone we want to be, and gender-switching titles would fail if they didn't appeal on that level.

Of course, it's a far cry from slipping on a new skin to getting some same-sex skin. Maybe you don't want to play as a gay character. That's fine. Maybe someone who's gay doesn't want to play as a straight character. That's fine, too. But I don't have any trouble thinking up titles that enforce a strictly heterosexual agenda. Find me the game that imposes a homosexual point of view.

Franchises like The Old Republic, Dragon Age, Mass Effect, and Fable always give you the choice. It's an option to accept or decline. That's also part of the fantasy...you control what happens. And with whom.


You had me at "I'll pay you lots of money to kill people."

And hey, if you want to experiment, good luck finding a safer environment. I'm talking about single-player gameplay, of course, far away from the online matches where "gay" and "fag" are always derogatory. Funny...those are compliments when my gay friends use them.

So when a bunch of lobbyists, using tactics I've frequently seen hate groups employ, attempt to disinvite whole populationsfrom civil society (albeit a virtual one) because they're afraid of contact contamination -- or, at the very least, institute a Don't Ask, Don't Tell policy -- I've got to shake my head. They just don't know what they're dealing with. You've got 12-year-olds rolling as sexy 30ish female assassins and blatantly racist homophobes already running riot online. Sometimes, that's the same person. But then, those interest groups' righteous outrage has less to do with gaming than it does with grabbing some press on a hot-button issue in the middle of an election year.

That said, they're right about one thing. The "gay agenda" has got to go, because "agenda" suggests something remains to be proven or defended. We need to reach a place -- one often depicted in BioWare games -- where sexual identity and preferences lack any sense of scandal. Certainly, we as gamers never felt ashamed when creating or playing an identity outside of our normal selves. That's a courtesy we should extend to real people.

If that fails, here's an idea: Go play something else. Alone.

 
Problem? Report this post
RUS MCLAUGHLIN'S SPONSOR
Comments (8)
Default_picture
April 10, 2012

Good article about the current faux-controversey!

The way EA handled the protesting from the homophobic masses was fairly admirable for such a large corporation. They did the right thing, despite being voted the worst company evar (from a bunch of short sighted idiots).

With oil spills and mercenaries existing, you would think that EA would be off the list completely. Plus, everyone knows Activision is the worst company.

Anyway, back to the issue.
This really should not be an issue. The fact that most people are looking at these gay-bashing morons and basically saying "Uh...Uh-huh. Well, we are going to continue into the 21st century, thanks." is a testament to how much things have changed, and how positive the gaming community can be.

Now, I don't have any problem with gay people myself, but only as long as they show it off in front of my proverbial kids. Little bastards need to learn that it's okay, after all.

Default_picture
April 10, 2012

Wow. This article was fantastic and witty! You brought to light many things that I was blind to about the way we perceive gender and sexual orientation in video games. Great read and keep writing!

Default_picture
April 10, 2012

Good stuff.

It's a shame we live in the year 2012 (i.e., The Future) and nonsense like "the gay agenda" is still touted by social conservative nutjobs.

Default_picture
April 11, 2012

I don't know what The Gay Agenda is, but I thought this line might be it:

"Games need more gender-bending sexual experimentation, not less."

I'm not against homogay, but I don't want extraneous themes added to my games that only serve to make a political statement. In other words, I want homolust in games about homogays, but I don't want it added just because a game dev thinks the subject of homosex needs to have equal exposure.

I would feel the same way if some game dev were going out of his way to artificially incorporate marriage into games just for political reasons.

I think all topics in games should occur naturally out of creativity and without anyone calling for censorship.

Default_picture
April 11, 2012

I think this totally depends on the game. Titles that are popular currently often tend to be open ended games where you control an avatar rather than a character. In that sort of situation I think it is expected that you should have the choice to be as queer as you want to be. Even when there IS a character involved, such as in Bully, you are free enough to do what you want--and if the game lets you make out with girls, there should be a guy option (such as in Bully).

Arguing that games should allow for experimentation (of gender and sexuality) is a fair point of contention. Unless a game is trying to tell a specific sort of story about a specific sort of character (such as "Johnny Straight fights the martians", or "Lonnie Notalesbian battles the Chimera") why not allow the avatar to bend gender, or be gay? Why can't my burly Fallout 3 character where the female version of sexy sleepwear?

Default_picture
April 11, 2012

Even as a Christian I believe there is nothing wrong with putting gays or lesbians in a game.  As you say, if you want your character to be homosexual, let them be.  It's not hurting your ability to play a straight character at all.  Even in Mass Effect 3, the gay man will hit on you one time if you are a guy.  It's not even an overt attempt.  You can politely decline him and he is entirely okay with it.  No harm, no foul.  What's the harm in that?  My Shepard continued to be his friend and went on to make sweet love to his full trilogy love Ashley.

Default_picture
April 12, 2012

Jeff, I'm not against adding homosex to games in principle. If it allows better gameplay and immersion, then I say go all out homoqueer. If the dev personally likes the topic, then I'd be ok with a bunch of homogaiety in any game. If the audience wants the topic of queerlove then by all means start adding it to games.

But, what I don't like is people saying that games -need- to add a theme or idea (any idea, it could be African child soldiers or Japanese whaling) just to help promote it in the industry or give it "equal" exposure. It feels out of place, like product placement in television and games.

Btw, I don't think any games in this article are guilty of that. Their additions of homolust seem to be inserted naturally and they do offer deeper, more stimulating gameplay. Just to clear that up.

Default_picture
April 13, 2012

My pants were slightly moist after reading this article.

PS: My Katawa Shoujo preview fits perfectly with the "You've got 12-year-olds rolling as sexy 30ish female assassins" except this time, It's kids who like girls with drills and bubblegum hair :D

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.