How NCAA Football 12 trolled me into becoming a prima donna

230340423
Friday, July 29, 2011

Put me in, Coach.

I’m ready. You know I’m ready. I’ve been killing it all game. I’ve got 130 yards rushing and two touchdowns. I just ripped off a 44-yard gain. I got this. Gimme the rock. Put me in.

...Or don’t. Yeah, that’s fine. I’ll just sit here on the sideline as our offense stalls on the goal line. I’ll just stand, stone-faced and silent, as our defense blows another lead I got for us. I won’t say a thing as I watch my season -- my Heisman hopes -- go down the drain. Whatever you want, Coach.

If you want to win, you know where to find me.

Sounds like the same attitude you might hear from a thousand arrogant athletes, right? Well, that’s what NCAA Football 12’s Road to Glory mode has reduced me to. I’ve become everything I always hated in sports. And I think the game trolled me into it.

 

Haters gonna hate, Coach. Haters gonna hate.

Road to Glory is the latest in EA Sports’ assortment of modes where you create a player and follow his career from high school to the big time. Like the Be a Pro modes in other titles, you only control your player, not the whole team. That means you have to play your role, whatever that role is.

That part is surprisingly fun. My created player is a running back, and I actually enjoyed learning how to pass block, how to run a wheel route, and when to release on a screen pass. It’s even fun when your quarterback decides not to pass to you, because it probably means you weren’t that open.

On the other hand, playing as just one player also means you’re not calling the plays yourself. You have to take what the coach sends in from the sideline. And that, I’m here to tell you, is an exercise in frustration. Third down and one yard to go? Coach might call a wide receiver screen. Second and 15? Draw play. First and goal? Four verticals. It can defy all football logic.

Does this look like a man who wants to sit out for a series? I didn't think so.

You can get around these boneheaded decisions by developing Coach Trust, which allows you to override your coach’s choices a certain number of times a game, depending on how hard you’ve worked in practice and how well you’ve performed on the field. The downside? It only gives you two extra play options, which are usually as irrational as the first one was.

The other factor to consider is fatigue. In real-life football, if a player breaks off a big run, he’ll probably get subbed out for a play so he can catch his breath. But Road to Glory doesn’t keep you out for just one play. It’ll make you watch for a whole series as your offense inevitably bungles the opportunity you set up for them.

(I’m not sure if the game provides a way to override this. I was too busy seething with rage.)

I'm pretty sure I'm pointing at the second-string running back to stay the hell off the field.

Of course, no matter what you do on offense, you still have to sit and watch when the other team has the ball. And maybe it’s just because my team (BYU) has never been known for great defense...but they can’t stop anybody. Worse, they seem to blow leads so quickly that no amount of careful clock management on offense can compensate for it.

Can you blame me for getting a little big-headed? I’m carrying this team. I have to do everything myself. And we still end up losing.

Maybe NCAA Football 12 is trying to teach me a lesson about team play and the importance of personal sacrifice for the greater good. Maybe the game is trying to show me that being a prima donna doesn’t work. Maybe I should....

...wait, Coach is putting me in? Never mind. I’m about to destroy these fools.

It’s all me, baby. All. Me.

 
Problem? Report this post
LAYTON SHUMWAY'S SPONSOR
Comments (21)
Default_picture
July 29, 2011

Trust a Zoobie to feel guilty for playing a video game.

230340423
July 29, 2011

Okay, did one of my friends make a fake Bitmob account just to bring some lame BYU/Utah smack talk? Truly, I have arrived as a writer. :)

Default_picture
August 01, 2011

I've been frustrated as the QB quite a few times. It seems like any time my team falls a couple scores behind the coach wants to run as if they've given up. I certainly lose more often in this year's game as I could get through all four seasons of Road to Glory with no losses in past versions. The defense does blow it too but then I'm not playing on a great team (Arizona State) and the team ratings got worse in the second season. I thought my amazing comeback in whatever-bowl-game-I've-never-heard-of that I was in would get some good recruits, guess not. I'm halfway into the second season now and since I can audible whenever I want I'm always running pass plays. That makes it easier though I've still lost a few times. One problem is I like to scramble and the tackles can get me knocked out of the game, usually for a quarter. The other problem is my receivers enjoy dropping passes. It's always their fault, not mine :)

Shoe_headshot_-_square
August 02, 2011

That is a stupid first screenshot.

Shoe_headshot_-_square
August 02, 2011

Also, are those BYU uniforms supposed to go from gray to blue back to gray?

Dscn0568_-_copy
August 02, 2011

It might be because the second pic is in the rain, so the lighting is darker and the uniform might be soaking wet.

Shoe_headshot_-_square
August 02, 2011

I don't buy it. I think it's because Layton doesn't care enough about his team to worry about such details when he's color-correcting screenshots.
 

230340423
August 02, 2011

Haha, it was just the rain, Shoe! And in the second screenshot (with Texas) I was using BYU's throwback "royal blue" jerseys rather than their current dark blue ones.

Mindjack
August 02, 2011

The second picture is so confusing! Texas player #17 is both behind and in front of the guy in the blue jersey.

That last image is taking place either underwater, or in space.

12316_390964573856_517183856_3883870_3650368_n
August 02, 2011

I originally read the title of this article as "How NCAA Football trolled me into becoming a dude named Donna."

230340423
August 02, 2011

I would play that game.

Robsavillo
August 02, 2011

Interesting concept, but I can't imagine that waiting on the sidelines for long stretches is all that entertaining. In choosing to play one specific role, wouldn't that of coach be the most compelling? I mean...in Populous, for example, you play the deity, not one of the followers.

Default_picture
August 02, 2011

The article does make it sound like you have to wait but you can just hit a button to skip until you're back on the field. In Road to Glory mode the games go quite fast that way, they only take me about 15 minutes. I think you can play as a coach in the Dynasty mode.

Robsavillo
August 02, 2011

Oh OK, that makes much more sense! Thanks.

230340423
August 02, 2011

Yeah, sorry, I forgot to explain that. Many times I WOULD watch the next play, though, just to see what happened. That was...unwise.

Jayhenningsen
August 02, 2011

I'm not sure I could relinquish control like that. If I did a good job and the computer still lost the game, that would get frustrating really fast.

Demian_-_bitmobbio
August 02, 2011

I played this mode in the last NHL game I spent serious time with, but I made a fatal mistake -- my player was a center for the Red Wings, which meant that when I finally made it to the top line, I replaced Pavel Datsyuk. The whole point is to play on a line *with* Datsyuk and Zetterburg!

Anyway. The way it worked in hockey was that you were in charge of line changes, so while you weren't on the ice all of the time, at least it was up to you to decide when you were.

230340423
August 02, 2011

Yeah, it seems to make much more sense in NHL. The key, though, is that you don't have a coach calling specific plays in the NHL games.

And I did the same thing a few years ago with the Leafs and Mats Sundin. Mistake.

Portrait
August 02, 2011

In the game, I get to enjoy Road to Glory mode where my blue-chip quarterback wins another national championship and Heisman Trophy for the mighty Colorado Buffaloes. In real life, I get to enjoy Road to a Mediocre Bowl Game mode where my cautious optimism slowly erodes into jaded pessimism.

230340423
August 02, 2011

Is Colorado even gonna make a bowl game this year? They have a TOUGH schedule, and it's their first year in the Pac-12. 

Rm_headshot
August 02, 2011

Of course, there's also the fact that Layton's angling for that Nike endorsement deal.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.