Kana: Little Sister review

There184
Sunday, February 21, 2010

Kana: Little Sister is a mindfuck. Not like The Matrix or A Scanner Darkly, but in a much more down-to-Earth way. It's a Japanese visual novel (think choose-your-own-adventure book with illustrations and sound) about a young man called Taka, and his relationship with his sickly little sister, Kana.

Kana spends almost all of her life in hospital due to renal insufficiency -- her kidneys don't function properly, causing all sorts of problems and forcing her onto a dialysis machine every week.

Taka bullies his little sister but when he is ten-years-old, an event forces him to re-evaluate their relationship and become a better brother. You then join Taka for ten years, visiting Kana in hospital and showing her the world outside.

Kana can juggle

Kana is two years younger than Taka. As they grow up Taka begins to confuse his co-dependency with his sister, and his affection for her with sexual urges. It's definitely uncomfortable, but developer D.O. does a very good job of making it believable -- having it gradually build, and the main character resist it with self-disgust. At the very end you can have sex with Kana. The way this is justified, although credible, seems like an afterthought.

Everyone writing about this game categorizes it as an eroge (erotic/porn game). The two sex scenes I clicked through seemed utterly disposable though. The developers must have agreed with me, as they were once remaking it for the original Xbox -- and there's no way Microsoft (or any other major console manufacturer) would allow pornography on their console. Perhaps it's unfair to criticize this for it's pornographic merit, but I didn't find it at all titillating.

The two main female characters are very exploitative; Kana couldn't be more pitiful if she was a three-legged puppy and Yumi, your traditional girlfriend character, seems to live only for you.

After she hurts him in grade-school, Taka hates Yumi until they meet again at college. All this time she has been unable to love anyone but him. There's nothing particularly appealing about Taka, so the idea that this ideal girl has been waiting for him falls flat. She has little more dimension than any female character in Western pornography -- a vacuous beauty who only finds pleasure in the player's avatar.

I can pick other nits: spelling mistakes in the English translation, a cheesy soundtrack, an implication that child-Taka is molested which is never resolved. I was on the verge of tears several times though, shared Taka's disgust with himself at others, and was left temporarily dumb-struck even by the non-canonical, unhappy ending I reached. (There are 6 endings, only one of them happy. One of the sad endings is canonical.)

Apparently fans point to Kana: Little Sister as the best example of a visual novel. It's the only one I've played, but if you don't mind your brain being assaulted by incestuous themes and an extremely depressing story, it's the most emotionally exhaustive and effective drama I've seen in a video game.

This review was spotlighted here.

http://www.bitmob.com/index.php/mobfeed/tags/kana-little-sister
 
Problem? Report this post
ALEX MARTIN'S SPONSOR
Comments (5)
Default_picture
February 21, 2010
It's good to hear about a visual novel (slightly eroge-esque) game that goes beyond seeing how you get into the pants of one of the vastly vapid girls you get to court.And this wouldn't be the firs time I've been assaulted by such themes in a mature manner.
Photo_on_2010-08-03_at_16
February 21, 2010
Have you ever played True Love? It's an interesting eroge game that in many ways is a precursor to Persona 3 and 4's Social Link system. It has an entertaining story, endearing characters and cheesy, catchy music. And, well, shagging.
There184
February 21, 2010

@Antonio Perhaps "assaulted" was a bad choice of words. It's challenging, but it doesn't feel like it was designed to shock. I was tying the article up with the "mindfuck" in the first paragraph though.

@Pete Kana is my introduction to visual novels. I'll seek out True Love though.

A friend recommended this to me when I told him about the little sister character in Persona 4. (Avoiding spoilers, but skip this paragraph if you're hyper-sensitive.) There's a part where Nanako gets sick and you can avenge her; I felt so attached to Nanako at that point that I just wanted to kill that guy, even though it wasn't what the game wanted me to do.

If this is what Japanese people think porn is then they are even weirder than I thought.

Franksmall
February 22, 2010
I have always wanted to try a visual novel, but haven't yet because I thought they were all only in Japanese... Not that I have done too much research on them. I might have to try this out. I loved the article!
There184
February 24, 2010

@Frank And I loved your comment. :-)

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.