Put the "Chinese" back into Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars

Default_picture
Thursday, June 25, 2009
Editor's Note: Allen brings up a good point -- there really isn't a lot of Asian main characters in Western games. Though last year's Mirror's Edge featured an Asian protagonist who wasn't a ninja, samuari, or a gangster. Way to ignore stereotypes, EA! -Michael



Huang Lee

?????? (or I know how to speak Cantonese)

When Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars was announced on the PSP, one of the first issues discussed on various gaming podcasts and gaming forums was how the gameplay might transfer from the touch screen controls and dual screen display of the DS to the PSP. And while that's certainly a concern, an entirely different question entered my head -- who will they hire to voice the characters?

 

See, one of the big problems I had with the DS version was the writing. The story was fine for what it was, but given that it was based around the antics of Hong Kong immigrants, I didn't expect dialog that was taken straight out of English vernacular. I know it's nearly impossible to do "accents" or even foreign languages in text, but I just felt it was very unusual for Huang to speak English as if he grew up in Liberty City.

One of the signature elements of Grand Theft Auto 4 was the fact that Niko and Roman were Eastern Europeans with Eastern European accents. They were undeniably immigrants and their story was meant to touch on the fallacy of the American dream. Indeed, the most famous line from the game is most likely Roman's "Let's go see beeeeeg American teetees" -- a line only memorable because of Roman's affected and over-the-top accent.

My hope is that with the port to the PSP, they'll add voiceovers to all the characters and try to reintroduce an element of ethnicity to the game. It's extremely rare to see Asian characters in Western games -- especially as the lead characters -- and to rob them of any racial and ethnic authenticity seems like a missed opportunity, especially in light of Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas and GTA4.

And it's not like it's unprecedented. The Chinese characters in GTA4 spoke Cantonese and accented English, so Rockstar had previously went to the trouble of trying to make Liberty City more ethnic than they had to. I just hope that they show the same consideration when thinking about how to improve the presentation for the PSP version. It would just be extremely disappointing if the port ends up featuring a full soundtrack but generic English American voice actors. Rockstar has a chance to make Chinatown Wars as relevant as any other GTA game and I sincerely hope they take it.

 
Problem? Report this post
ALLEN KWAN'S SPONSOR
Comments (7)
Lance_darnell
June 26, 2009
I am totally with you, for the PSP offers the capacity and horsepower to DO voiceovers. But, I fear that voiceovers will not be done.... >:(
Default_picture
June 26, 2009
I agree with this post. I also believe that they should take advantage of the PSP's superior sound chip. One of the things that made the DS game unbearable was how bad the music was.
Default_picture
June 26, 2009
I wish Kazuka 3 would have came state side.
37425_412468101714_719286714_4780931_4814727_n
June 27, 2009
I'm in the same boat with Lance on this one. Being how poorly Chinatown Wars did on the DS, to go back and hire voice actors for all of the dialog on the chance that it will sell well on PSP may not be a smart business decision.
Default_picture
June 27, 2009
Yeah, that's a distinct possibility. But hopefully they'll go back and improve the production values in order to sell it as an "enhanced" version in an effort to convince the people who bought the DS version. And I actually completely forgot about [i]Mirror's Edge[/i]. It's probably because the game was in first person and Faith is featured more prominently in the marketing materials than in the game itself.
Default_picture
June 27, 2009
I honestly don't understand why people keep saying this game did poorly. Half a million in worldwide sales in less than six months sounds pretty good for a handheld title. Probably won't hit the same level of sales as the PSP GTA games, but still, it's done well for a 3rd party title.
Shoe_headshot_-_square
June 28, 2009
I hear the kid (now grown-up) who played Short Round in The Temple of Doom is looking for work. I am, too...but I sound pretty midwestern. :/ BTW, "a guest" above...you've registered your name with some illegal characters that our system doesn't recognize...that's causing a bug to make your name show up like that. If you take out punctuation (we prefer just your first and last name), it should fix that problem. Thanks.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.