How Rock Band taught me I'm allowed to sing

There184
Wednesday, January 12, 2011
EDITOR'S NOTEfrom Layton Shumway

I can totally identify with Alex's experience. I've been playing music and singing since I was very young, but games like Rock Band have encouraged me -- and others -- to continue to develop those talents outside of the gaming world. And that's a good thing.

Rock Band

It's my turn to sing, and the song is Maps by the Yeah Yeah Yeahs. I don't know the song, but I know this is a female-fronted band. And I can't sing. A loop of a single note on guitar plays, and our drummer follows the complicated introduction almost perfectly. Some words appear on the right of the screen.

Next, something unexpected happens -- words come out of my mouth, sung in lead singer Karen O's register, and the game tells me I'm "awesome!"

I know it's exaggerating -- I'm playing on a lower difficulty, and my singing is soft to conserve energy and not draw attention to myself. But it's still encouraging. After a few songs I step up the difficulty to hard, then to expert. I feel my voice getting more accurate as the game gives real-time feedback. With my five gold stars for "Creep," I can supposedly call myself 99% of Thom Yorke.

I'm not going to say Rock Band's made me a good singer -- that's totally different from getting a good score, even at the highest difficulty level. But its visual feedback has helped. It's also let me know that I'm allowed to sing -- I can sing -- even though I'm not up to a high standard.

 

I played the original Rock Band in the kitchen of a student flat in Lancaster, with friends on bass, drum, and guitar. Eventually, we started playing our real instruments together in a practice room. I was on guitar (I was already a decent guitar player) and vocals.

Rock Band has helped me get over any anxiety about singing in front of small groups. I wouldn't have thought, before, to pick up my guitar and sing a song, but Rock Band has got my voice to a standard at which that's fun for me (and not excruciating for those around me).

Rock Band 3 is attempting to do the same with instruments. The "pro" drums, keyboards, and guitars are all actual instruments. Even that guitar with the buttons can be played through a computer or MIDI device, although it is not as guitar-like as its stringed big brother.

I'll be surprised if anyone completely masters an instrument using Rock Band alone, but the series is doing more to bring musical performance to the masses than any one band is doing. Motivated kids have been picking up guitars and microphones since way before music games, but by sneaking them into living rooms, Harmonix is showing people who hadn't thought about it that, actually, musicianship is fun and not as unattainable as they might've thought.


Has Rock Band got you into musicianship? Have you picked up a pro guitar and learned something -- or did you find the experience overwhelming? I'd love to hear your thoughts.

 
Problem? Report this post
ALEX MARTIN'S SPONSOR
Comments (5)
Default_picture
January 13, 2011

Nice to hear this game is helping you set your voice free so to speak. It's always an amazing feeling to learn new skills, especially in music.

However, RockBand is a GAME. It is really just a glorified karaoke.  By no means is it going to teach you to master a musical instrument on any level of competency.

Being a musician myself I know that it takes years of dedication and practice to learn to play an instrument and sing "unaccompanied". (It is one thing to sing along a piece of music, something entirely different to MAKE music) 

So please, do yourself a big favour and stop deluding yourself into thinking this video game can teach you to be a musician. It aint gonna happen.

There184
January 13, 2011

I'm pretty sure I conceded in the article that you need more than just Rock Band to learn an instrument completely. It can get you on the way to that though.

Jayhenningsen
January 13, 2011

Walter - Video games can teach us how to read, type, do math, and a host of other things. I don't think it's such a stretch that they could eventually teach someone to play an instrument. Nobody is saying that video games are a replacement for hard work, but they certainly could be an alternate form of learning. There's no reason you can put as much time into a properly crafted game and get similar results. It's more about the time spent practicing than whether or not you're doing it under the context of a video game.

37893_1338936035999_1309080061_30825631_6290042_n
January 13, 2011

I don't know Alex, I've heard your irresistable accent from across the pond. You might be better than you think.

There184
January 13, 2011

@Chase I wasn't trying to fish for complements, but thanks!

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.