Don't be offended, I think Scribblenauts is really cool! Just not as a game. It's clever, it's more of a developer tool, but the actual gameplay of Scribblenauts just isn't fun.
Jumping into shark infested waters because I was trying to move Max towards an object I needed him to pick up just isn't fun, it's annoying. Or when I move the screen to see what the level has to offer, or try and figure out a puzzle, only to have the camera stick in that spot no matter what I do, you know there's something wrong. Perhaps with a few tweaks and better control, Scribblenauts would be a pleasure to play. As it stands, it's my Best Worst Most Annoying Game of 2009.