Confronting Ozymandias: The struggle to preserve gaming history

Default_picture
Friday, November 30, 2012
EDITOR'S NOTEfrom Rob Savillo

In 50 years, will you still be able to play your favorite games of today? That's what Nathaniel is concerned with, and he's looking back now as thousands of titles from decades past slip into obscurity or, worse, become lost due to ever-evolving technology.

You could say I’m a bit perturbed. After watching one of the most recent videos from the team at Extra Credits (this one, which I wholly recommend watching), I’m beginning to worry to about the lack of preservation in our industry.

 

Now, I know digital download services like Steam and Nintendo’s Virtual Console have revitalized developers’ back catalogues, but some titles still fall through the cracks because of copyright issues or other problems the publisher or developer simply isn't willing to face.


I met a traveller from an antique land
Who said: Two vast and trunkless legs of stone
Stand in the desart.
 

Titles like the N64's GoldenEye and the GameCube's Eternal Darkness, though incredibly important to our history, can’t be found on any store shelves or download catalogues (unless you happen to live in the most amazing city ever). And though they can still be found used, only a finite amount of cartridges and discs exist. I doubt we’ll ever run out of them, but how long is it before we’re paying $40 to $70 for a game that came out years ago?

This is a distressing problem for the gaming public, but I’m far more concerned about the development and critical sides of the industry. The ramifications of a generation without knowledge of the past would be disastrous, but their resulting creative works could be even more so. Everyone who plans on working in this industry needs to know our shared past; this way, we’ll be able to work together toward creating a shared future.

The next generation of writers, critics, and developers need to experience certain things -- shouldn’t they be able to?


Near them, on the sand,
Half sunk, a shattered visage lies, whose frown,
And wrinkled lip, and sneer of cold command,
Tell that its sculptor well those passions read
 

I’m glad to see more companies addressing this problem by rereleasing titles on platforms like Steam or the App Store, but the team at Extra Credits brought up another valid point: Touch-based control schemes are butchering classics.

Pac-Man may work on just about every device known to man, but Battlezone quickly loses appeal without its arcade cabinet. I would much rather have a port of Grand Theft Auto III on my iPhone with a few control issues than nothing at all, but what about the 10-year-old who may one day grow into a writer or developer thinking that the first 3D game in the series was only a stepping stone for Rockstar’s later efforts? And will they even know that it was the first 3D Grand Theft Auto?

I know they mean well, but some experiences just can’t be replicated without the proper care. That’s why I’m so excited for SNK with the imminent release of their Neo Geo X; it seems as if the company truly wants people to be able to experience its piece of gaming history as originally intended.

But at the same time, I see companies that either no longer exist or operate in a much smaller capacity whose consoles that can only be purchased through online retailers at high prices. Vectrex, Atari Jaguar, Philips CD-i -- they’re not cheap, and I suspect very few people would be willing to acquire them.

These problems haunt me. Are we leaving a legacy, or are we striving so hard to get somewhere that we refuse to see where we’ve been?


Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things,
The hand that mocked them and the heart that fed:
And on the pedestal these words appear:
"My name is Ozymandias, king of kings:
Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!"
 

This is just as much my fault as any else’s; when I go through the lists of history’s most influential games, I can barely recognize any from before 1995. I’ve been doing my best to fill in the gaps by playing various collections, watching informative Internet videos, and doing even simple things such as reading up on now-defunct development studios -- anything to avoid letting ignorance become an acceptable standard.

What bothers me is that few others seem to be interested in preserving our origins -- outside of those who were able to experience them firsthand. Perhaps what impresses me the most, though, is the dedication of those who do still remember. The Videogame History Museum, All Your History, and even Did You Know Gaming? have all reinvigorated interest in the days of yore, and I can’t possibly begin to imagine how much good has come from their observation and preservation.

Unfortunately, their methods also confront me with a problem: Informing the public only serves to acknowledge the past. Admirers will see the rarities, not experience them, and therein lies the problem. With other mediums, it is much easier for aspiring artists and wordsmiths to interact with the classics from other eras. Art museums showcase exact replicas, and the Internet can provide detailed approximations. Film critics and creators can appreciate classics through DVD, Blu-ray, and digital rereleases. We, on the other hand, are forced to either find and preserve what we still have or emulate what we don’t.

No matter the choice, our options are looking bleaker as time passes and more titles are forgotten or abandoned.


Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
 

Much of our past has been ignored so that more focus can be placed on the present, and that may be the ultimate outcome of this issue, but I’m determined to never let that be my outcome. As any good student of world history would know, the past has the eerie tendency to mirror the future. Without realizing it, many have only repeated their predecessors’ actions when they believed themselves to be doing something never done before.

We may never be able to appreciate our history as much as other art forms do simply because we’ve failed to properly care for it until now, but I don’t think we’ll ever be entirely devoid of a legacy. People spurred on by the stories and experiences of others will keep interest alive, and hopefully the next generation will learn from our mistakes.


Captions from "Ozymandias" by Percy Bysshe Shelley.

 
Problem? Report this post
NATHANIEL DZIOMBA'S SPONSOR
Comments (5)
Default_picture
November 30, 2012

As an old school gamer (I turned 40 this year) and a film critic, I worry about these issues too. So many movies have been lost to time because no one took the form seriously enough to preserve them back in the day, and I see the same thing happening to games. 

As someone who loves the medium (and is a collector who owns over a thousand games), this makes me sad. We've already lost access to so many great titles, and it seems likely to get worse before it gets better.

Great post. 

Assassin_shot_edited_small_cropped
November 30, 2012

It's actually even worse than you think. The history of video games is literally rotting away, as storage media fails and master disks disappear before they can be preserved. The people who would act before it's too late are hamstrung by overzealous copyright laws.

I went into much greater detail in a feature article earlier this year (and will do so again with a specific sub-section of preservation in a few months). Check it out if you're interested, and don't be afraid to ask me questions. http://archive.vg/blog/12-feature/36-the-perils-challenges-and-uncertainty-of-collecting-and-preserving-video-games

Default_picture
November 30, 2012

I'm still sad that new gamers haven't been able to experience certain classic game series when they first started. Some people love Telltale Games' Sam & Max series, but the franchise hit its prime in its first PC game, Sam & Max Hit the Road.

I'm sure that some people might try to revive these games later on, but they'll never replicate the experience when we first played them. They can't capture the anxiety when we first tried playing them with a lame single-speed CD drive. They can't show us all the issues that plagued old 3D graphics cards, such as the Diamond Monster 3D.

I know that many franchises have various licensing issues that have kept publishers from re-releasing them (Goldeneye as the biggest example). It shouldn't be like this. We really should find some way to revive these classics in some sort of Criterion Collection format. Otherwise, they will remain forgotten and disregarded by newer generations to come.

Default_picture
November 30, 2012

Shouldn't your classics compare with the classics of someone who is younger than you?  I'm in my early-20s which means that my classic games are most likely different than someone's who is in their 30s or 40s.  As someone who missed out a lot of early PC gems like XCOM and Baldur's Gate, I can't really go back and experience them at all.  The interfaces are just too unwieldy and unfun to accomodate to.

Digital is both the way of the future and a bit of a handicap.  I would love for EVERY game to have some digital form, even if such a thing is impossible.  How great would it be to finally get to play Eternal Darkness or System Shock 2 (legally, at least)?

However, we have to be careful how these games come about.  Good Old Games has done the best with this and its DRM-free games.  I don't see Nintendo or Microsoft being so generous.  Games from the Xbox Live Marketplace may very well (and have in the past) vanish forever.  I don't want to pay for something that may just disappear from my posession, but I don't really want to pay $50-80 for older games either.

Default_picture
December 01, 2012

I realize that I am a bit of an extreme purist. I'm the crazy person who figured out how to play my ancient Return to Zork CD from back in 1992. And yes, it is just as awful and campy as it was when it first came out.

At the same time, I considered it as part of a learning experience. All these unwieldy systems taught developers how to improve on a lot of the awful interfaces of the past. I'd just hate to think that people would forget about those days, as if they never existed.

I really shouldn't fret about these titles going out of print. However, I'd also hate to hide it away from all Internet distribution, like a pirate. And I just really miss a lot of old treasures. Especially the first Sam & Max point-and-click adventure.

Then again, there are many other existing titles that furthered the development of the current gaming universe. I guess I just have to accept that some great treasures may not see the light of day again, unless everyone joins together to publish them in peace and harmony. Damn, I just really miss Goldeneye.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.