Do goalie fights in NHL 12 belong in Hell?

Jon_ore
Sunday, June 19, 2011

Jeff Blair, sports columnist for The Globe and Mail, commented in this Monday's paper about the upcoming unveiling of the cover athlete for EA Sports's NHL 12. Blair makes the obvious suggestion of Boston Bruins goalie Tim Thomas fresh off of his totally not riot-inducing Stanley Cup win, but takes more time noting one of the EA stalwart's new features: goalie fights.

"Goalies Drop the Gloves," notes EA's promotional site for NHL 12. "When the action boils over, send a message by leaving the net, dropping the gloves, and trading punches with a heated rival during fights."

Blair doesn't hide his venom for the idea. "Well, colour us thrilled! There really is a special place in hell for these people, no? No report on whether you can pick a city of your choice to burn after your team craps the bed in the playoffs."

Incendiary words to be sure. But that brings up what I think is a more legitimate question: are goalie fights really a good feature for hockey video games? I've always thought that sports games were an arena for gamers and fans to enact their own fantasy scenarios - a friend of mine regularly plays with the Toronto Maple Leafs and wins, for heaven's sake. And hockey fights have been a part of the games for years.

So here's my question, readers. Do hockey video games, and other sports games by extension, have a social responsibility not to promote the rougher, and sometimes dangerous, elements of a game? Or is it a good arena to play out all the fantastic and ridiculous scenarios possible?

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (1)
Demian_-_bitmobbio
June 20, 2011

I saw this game demoed (and played it a bit) at E3, and one of the things they were hyping was the goalie fights. The developer doing the demo said something like, "It's one of our most requested features -- goalie fights." And I thought to myself, really? And even if so, you're going to go ahead and do it?

Then he showed a goalie fight actually happen, and it was ridiculous. Two non-goalie players got into a fight on the ice, and then suddenly the camera cuts to center ice where the goalies are going toe to toe, with no one else around anywhere. I can't say it'll be like that in the final game, but what a dumb "feature." I'd rather see goalies have a chance to score with clearing attempts/rink-long shots when the other goalie's been pulled.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.