Separator

Gaming's critics wave the white flag

Default_picture
Saturday, April 02, 2011
EDITOR'S NOTEfrom Jay Henningsen

Did everyone suddenly come to their senses and start acting like rational adults who research topics before providing media sound bites? Read Jason's tale of hope.

Gaming is a dependable scapegoat for all that’s wrong with the world: violence, sexism, war, spousal abuse, teenage truancy, crime, and even global warming. And while psychologists, critics, and politicians (none of whom have played a video game since Pac-Man) lob wildly-uninformed charges, gamers, ironically, play a game of non-violent resistance. But the war rages on, claiming many casualties along the way. Thankfully, the long fight may finally be over; gaming's leading critics have waved the white flag.

Carole Lieberman M.D. is a psychiatrist and author of such literary classics as Bad Boys: Why We Love Them, How to Live with Them, and When to Leave Them, and Bad Girls: Why Men Love Them & How Good Girls Can Learn Their Secrets. Dr. Lieberman recently appeared on Fox News to discuss Bulletstorm, an over-the-top FPS. She’s since recanted some of her more egregious charges.

“When I said, ‘The increase in rapes can be attributed to the playing out of sexual scenes in video games,’ I admit that it was based on one inconclusive study and my own conjecture,” she told gaming website Bitmob.

 

The venerable psychiatrist recently got some hands-on time with Bulletstorm. “This is an extraordinarily entertaining piece of software!” she said. “I now understand the game’s tongue-in-cheek humor…I can’t believe I criticized this without ever playing it!” Dr. Lieberman told Bitmob that she has Duke Nukem Forever on pre-order, and she can’t wait for Modern Warfare 3.

As you may recall, Mass Effect caught flak for its optional romantic subplot. Conservative blogger Kevin McCullough led the charge, claiming that ME allows its players “to engage in the most realistic sex acts ever conceived.” “With its ‘over the net’ capabilities, virtual orgasmic rape is just the push of a button away,” he said.

Self-help author Cooper Lawrence joined the fray, comparing Mass Effect to porn and asserting that it contained “frontal nudity and explicit depictions of sexual activity.” When asked whether she’d played the game, Lawrence replied that she’d watched a 30-second Youtube clip spliced with Marvin Gaye’s “Let’s Get it On.”

On Monday, Bitmob was able to corral up McCullough and Lawrence for an all-night gaming session, leaving the two bleary-eyed. McCullough admitted that he may have overstepped his bounds. “I’d heard about Mass Effect’s ‘explicit sexuality’ from a friend of a friend of a friend, and accepted it at face value without playing the game or doing five minutes of research…how wrong I was,” McCullough said. “In fact, the romance in Mass Effect is very much consensual, and no more graphic or explicit than network TV.”

Even Lt. Col David Grossman, who labeled FPSs “murder simulators,” has backed off from prior statements. “Shooting a real firearm and playing Halo are two very different concepts,” he said. “I don’t see how playing a video game can possibly make you more proficient with firearms. Besides, have you seen the nerds who play video games? Tubby, uncoordinated, slovenly. They wouldn’t last five seconds in the Army.”

Grossman added that he’d be attending E3 this year. “I’m totally hooked,” he said.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (8)
Alexemmy
April 01, 2011

Oh what a perfect world this would be.

Dscn0568_-_copy
April 01, 2011

What an incredible moment of clarity.

April 02, 2011

A little out of timing, aren't you? April's Fool was yesterday.

April 02, 2011

oh, apparently, the post WAS made yesterday, because the comments are. But the header says Saturday, April 02. Anyway, nevermind my previous comment

Christian_profile_pic
April 02, 2011

We can dream ... we can dream....

Me
April 02, 2011

Now if Jack Thompson actually played the games he criticized.

Itsame_
April 03, 2011

@Christian Davis But I bet based on Jack's maturity level he would be more of a Saints Row guy. GTA is far too serious. 

Default_picture
April 03, 2011

Jack Thompson actually formed his own guild and is joining the Major League Gaming circuit.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.