Tim, I wish I bought
Your fun, fucking awesome gem
At full price. Encöre!
I'm hoping for an encore myself -- for both Brutal Legend and Psychonauts. Brendon is right; crafting interesting game worlds is definitely Schafer's strong suit, whereas the gameplay in Brutal Legend and Psychonauts fell a bit flat in both cases.
But as much as I'd love to see a couple of sequels, apparently Schafer would rather create new IP than revisit old properties. :\
Hmmm great open game world, fascinating and funny characters, narratives that suck you in and keep you enthralled, varied mission structures, interesting themes that speak to you on interesting levels.
I'm not going to piss on the gameplay. You got Devil May Cry and Bayonetta if combo-weaving matters more to you than all that other stuff, right? I thought it did a good job mixing up gameplay variety: RTS elements, good combat that is button-mash friendly, fun driving, all of it with character.
This is the kind of structure that could have worked with something serious too, like Starcraft: Ghost, if you ask me. More tuning and variety (maybe a bit too many ambushes) can come in the encore.