I am totally OK with assholes making video games

Andrewh
Tuesday, April 03, 2012
EDITOR'S NOTEfrom Rus McLaughlin

Back in college, a philosophy professor played our class two spectacular excerpts from a Beethoven symphony, recorded by two different orchestras in two different decades, and asked us to pick our favorite. Then he told us -- truthfully -- that one was performed in 1941 Berlin by card-carrying members of the Nazi party, and asked if that changed anyone's mind.

ShayOver the weekend, OMGpop CEO Dan Porter had some fairly crass things to say about Shay Pierce (pictured), the guy who didn’t move to Zynga after the social-media giant purchased the Draw Something developer. While those tweets have been deleted, his negative comments were well-documented.

Video game fans and pundits alike jumped on the situation with some very succinct and direct commentary of their own. If one believes the various tweets and message board comments, many gaming enthusiasts quickly uninstalled Draw Something and figuratively burned Mr. Porter in effigy.

I, somewhat new to the Draw Something phenomenon, looked on with some amount of agreement and a healthy dose of bemusement. I even went so far as to tweet that Mr. Porter was “vile, petty, and childish” and a “douchebag.” All true, if we judge his public persona as filtered through Twitter. What I didn't tweet, but would like to add now, is that I don’t particularly care. The idea of deleting Draw Something from your iOS device because one of its creators is an asshole is absolutely, positively rich with irony.

 

Say what you will about the late Steve Jobs, but three things are undeniably true:1.) He was a business genius. 2.) He was a design innovator. 3.) He was an irredeemable and unapologetic prick. That last point doesn't erase the fact that he pioneered the iPhone, iPad, and iPod upon which so many people played, then removed Draw Something in protest.

I won’t say that protest smacks of hypocrisy...that would be too hypocritical of me. I firmly believe that a certain amount of irony -- and an occasional lack of self-awareness -- is necessary for culture to chug along. I have to wonder, who did you think these people were, anyway? Saints? With so much of the development process communicated to us via sterile public relations channels, I find it so refreshing to see unfiltered and unchecked commentary. It lets us know that real, flawed humans live behind the squeaky clean PR firewall.

Besides, I kind of like the idea of assholes making video games.

Draw THIS Something!

And I’m talking about real assholes. Not these polished, practiced badasses that who frequently take center stage. I am sure that Cliff Bleszinski’s and Tomonobu Itagaki’s badassery comes from a place of honesty. Their public personas, however, feel either too media-trained (in the case of the former) or exaggerated (in the case of the latter). Assholes can be uncompromising, but that kind of singular, adamant vision can create great games.

So I want Fez developer Phil Fish to tell people to suck his dick. I want Nintendo sage Shigeru Miyamoto to flip tables in a tantrum at a posh restaurant. I want Nintendo executive Reggie Fils-Aime to kick ass physically, not just talk tough during a media briefing. I want Twisted Metal creator David Jaffe to insult interviewers if he feels the need.

As for Dan Porter, the co-founder of Zynga’s latest acquisition? I don’t mind if he spits fire at Shay Pierce, who did, after all, decide to take his personal politics into a very public forum. One does not call out a former employer without some self-confidence and conviction. Both Pierce and Porter will either weather the storm they created or get some comeuppance for punching above their weight-class. In either case, I’m comfortable with the result. If egos were bruised, they probably needed the abuse in the first place.

Ultimately, this incident shed light on one of video games' hottest properties and maybe the industry as a whole. Between Pierce's original post and Porter's response, we saw more than juicy soundbites and quick headlines. We witnessed people acting like jerks and saying what's really on their minds without obsessive PR watchdogs controlling the message. That's a rare and wonderful thing.

So give me more assholes making video games. Just don't make me draw one.

 
Problem? Report this post
ANDREW HISCOCK'S SPONSOR
Comments (20)
Img_1019
April 02, 2012
I dunno, It's not that won't buy a game made buy an asshole, but I prefer that people not be assholes. I don't think the qualities that make one an asshole are a bonus when it comes to making games. When was the last time Jaffe or Itagaki made a great game? They make one or two, burn every bridge, go somewhere else where they find out that it was the team that made their previous games great, and end up in an endless cycle of releasing mediocre games and burning bridges.
Andrewh
April 03, 2012

I prefer that people don't make assholes, but as someone who is interested in the industry behind his favorite hobby, this is the best way to see inside that industry. Perhaps something like those Irrational Podcasts is a good inbetween? here is a certain amount of candidness without compromising the positive message.

Your comment about longevity is interesting, and probably true. Look at what happened at Team Bondi -- that was interesting as all get-out, but we'll never see another LA Noire.

Robsavillo
April 02, 2012

I don't know. Not everyone can be GG Allin, and I don't even think video games are the right medium for that type of persona. This recent episode with Omgpop did make for some interesting reading, regardless.

But I can't deny the uncanny resemblance you have with Mr. Pierce, Andrew!

Andrewh
April 03, 2012

Interesting you should mention GG Allin. In a somewhat related note, I always felt weird about Suda 51 claiming the punk rock mantra. When applied to video games, does that mean Otaku with murder-fantasies and 5th Grade sex jokes? 

Ironically enough, we both wear glasses and beards in order to disguise the fact we are even more identical than you can imagine.

Robsavillo
April 03, 2012

Kill Screen had an interesting piece last week on applying punk rock ethos to video games. Definitely worth a read.

I see this association more frequently now. I, too, think it's weirdly off-base; I don't find much about games development as it exists now to actually be "punk rock" (whatever the loaded term means now...).

I think what I'm getting at is that the "asshole" attitude embodied in punk is fun and playful. The assholes in video games are just plain fucking assholes, taking petty cheap shots at each other and everyone else. They're people I'd rather not asociate myself with.

Default_picture
April 02, 2012

I don't really understand some of the reactions either.  He may be an asshole, but that has nothing to do with the game's playability. Sure, some people don't want their money to directly support someone like that, but every game studio has to have at least one douchebag. Maybe that person just knows better than to vent on twitter.

I'll take an honest opinion over PR speak any day.

Andrewh
April 03, 2012

For sure, concerning opinion over PR. BUt your comment about knowing better to vent on Twitter is interesting. I think they should all know better than to vent on Twitter -- they should still say what they want to say, but take it to a better forum than Twitter. Perhaps, though, Twitter is one of the few platforms that encourage candid behavior. Unfortunately, most platforms that indeed encourage candid behavior rarely offer the opportunity to elaborate fully.... (which, I suspect, if they could, they wouldn't have said anything in the first place).

Default_picture
April 03, 2012

Hmmmmm....

This Shay Pierce isn't nearly as big an asshole as Brendan McNamara (the L.A. Noire lead). Building games on exploited labor? That's what we should be talking about.

I can accept games being made by assholes; half the guys who work in programming or art probably hate their lives and had their dreams crushed. They're doing it just to collect a paycheck most of the time. But when we document a director or producer swearing on twitter, then the fans think its time to protest.

If we really saw how much blood, sweat, tears, and profanity it takes to get a game to market.... we probably wouldn't know whether to feel humbled or disgusted...

Default_picture
April 03, 2012

Uh...You do realise you just advocated beating women? You know that line you shouldn't cross?

Look behind you.

Andrewh
April 03, 2012

The violence against women joke wasn't in my original article, and I have nothing to do with it. I have requested to have it removed.

Default_picture
April 03, 2012

Um, I don't think he's saying something like that at all. In no way did he say to hit Olivia Munn with a "right cross to the jaw" because she's a woman. I may be wrong, but he might be referencing this specific incident between Jaffe and Munn: 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nIUt-a7iKac

Also, he just might not like her body of work. I think we should give Andrew the benefit of the doubt here before jumping to conclusions.

Andrewh
April 03, 2012

As noted above, I didn't make the reference, kind of don't know who Olivia Munn is, don't know about the incident, nor would ever joke about violence against women. The comment was inserted after I submitted my article. I know nothing more than that, and trying to correct it now.

Default_picture
April 03, 2012

Ah. Just FYI then: There's been a bit of a argument going on twitter among some game journos now over that joke, so sadly they do think it's associated with you...

Default_picture
April 03, 2012

Good to hear Andrew. Can't believe someone would add something like that to your article! Hope they sort it out for you quickly.

Funny-pictures-interesting-cat
April 03, 2012

Well, if you wanted tons of people to read your article I guess that's one way to do it...

On the constructive criticism front, maybe instead of pointing at ways that people could be assholes (or specifying which dick pimple should hit which "actress"), you could have elucidated a little bit. For example, tell us *why* you want these people to act irrantionally. You say it's acceptable behaviour, but it's unclear if you're saying this should be a bigger part of culture ("More brawls in Panera, please!") or if this behaviour has some direct affect on their work.

I'd like to think the latter, but regardless... I hope I don't meet you in that Panera anytime soon.

Andrewh
April 03, 2012

 

The violence against women joke wasn't in my original article, and I have nothing to do with it. I have requested to have it removed.

As for acting irrationally, I think they are acting quite rationally. Just in kind of negative ways. As noted, I think we can gain significant insights through conflict. 

And while I don't approve of brawls or violencem, flipping tables is kind of cool.

Anime_adam
April 03, 2012

I don't understand why you think game designers being assholes is going to make the games or the industry better in any way. It sounds like you're just excited for the press opportunities, and that doesn't seem like it'll help anything. Also, yes, assaulting women is a little more than a person being an asshole. Not super cool.

Andrewh
April 03, 2012

The violence against women joke wasn't in my original article, and I have nothing to do with it. I have requested to have it removed.

I guess I'm would be excited for press opportunities, insofar that they reveal more about video games that canned statements do.

I don't think designers being assholes make games better. I'm just not concerned that they make games. Big difference.

Default_picture
April 04, 2012

I think you are trying to say that we need to have people constantly question the status quo.  That it is not okay to stifle individuals who are trying to express themselves even if it seems offensive.  Because even though what they are trying to express may offend people, it may have value objectively.  

Default_picture
April 05, 2012

Thats what I got out of it. Not to have everyone hide behind a PR curtain but to be themselves, even if the media has a hayday about it. I don't think people should be hounded for honesty just because its something that the "General Populace" doesn't want to hear.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.