Separator

Why I'm not down with digitally distributed games (for now)

04596077bdbbd4327842d739accd8b0a
Friday, August 12, 2011
EDITOR'S NOTEfrom Rob Savillo

Digital acquisition of games through online services may be the future and all that, but we lose that lingering tradition of ownership when developers and publishers have such technological control over our purchases. Anti-consumer practices like download limits, install tokens, and always-on-Internet-connection requirements are just the beginning.

I see something special about rushing home to crack open a newly purchased video game. Before removing my jacket or throwing down my backpack, I run over to the living room and turn on my game console.

While the console slowly powers up, I use every bit of my fingernails to scratch open the stubborn plastic wrap. I start from the top and unravel the plastic around its body; my fingers are every bit as excited as the brain controlling them. It is nothing short of a magical moment.

More than music, books, or movies, I simply love buying video games in physical formats. Sometimes I actually like to arrange and play with the GameBoy and DS game cartridges themselves. There's nothing better than spending the morning hours of an overcast Sunday morning in bed stacking game cartridges like gambling chips or demolishing them like a real-life version of Boom Blox.
 
My DS game collection.
 
 
It's an incredibly dorky thing to do, I admit, but it's something I've been doing ever since childhood, and the experience is certainly part of why I feel connected with the gaming culture in general. I don't want to stop simply because all my games now reside in the cloud.
 
Don’t get me wrong; I have no issue buying music on iTunes or downloading apps from the App Store. But like a grandfather recalling the days of old, I fail to understand the appeal of purchasing core games digitally as opposed to owning traditional, retail copies.
 
 
Unlike buying music or other types of entertainment, downloading full games takes a long time. There have been nights where I thought, “Ah, I’ll just spend the rest of the evening playing whatever games I find on Steam.”
 
But only when I confirmed my order did I realize that the only entertainment for the rest of the night was watching the download bar's progress. Whereas I can begin watching the movie as it’s being downloaded, I have to download the entire game completely before I can proceed to install and enjoy the game. Digital delivery usually means instant gratification, but core games don’t have that advantage due to their sheer size as well as the relatively slow Internet connection many of us currently have today.
 
What’s makes even less sense to me is the concept of buying games digitally for home consoles. Hard drives fail and things happen. On a PC, I can at least back up my games, wipe my hard drive, perform a fresh install, and start over. But what happens if my console eventually fail and its warranty has since expired? Unlike the previous generation of game consoles where I can simply swap out the memory cards and games onto other working consoles, there’s no easy option for me to back up my games that are stored on the hard drive (as well as the saved data associated with the games). I can’t perform a fresh install even if I’m able to because Sony might take me to court.
 
I understand the PlayStation Store has a five-time download limit to purchased content, so I should be able to re-download them onto another working unit if necessary. But I pay to own my content on my PC as much as I do on my PlayStation 3, so why can’t I treat them the same way?
 
With Steam being so successful and with the recent launch of the Electronic Arts’ Origin service, I wonder if retail games will suffer the same fate as music, books, and so many types of digital media that are now living in the cloud. Maybe I’ll be less of a skeptic in a few years when we’re able to download a full game within minutes, but until then, my nostalgia and my constant fear of Murphy’s Law is keeping me from hopping to the digital bandwagon.
 
Problem? Report this post
WINSON SHUEN'S SPONSOR
Comments (10)
Dscn0568_-_copy
July 14, 2011

When I'm cleaning my shelves I do like to lay my games and books out just to gaze upon them. Even with the move to digital distribution I still like owning hard copies of my games.

04596077bdbbd4327842d739accd8b0a
July 14, 2011

Yeah, and I even love flipping through the instruction manuals when I'm not playing. That's what happens when you have an older brother who doesn't know how to share :]

167586_10100384558299005_12462218_61862628_780210_n
August 12, 2011

I have to admit that I'm terrified of the idea that the games that I download on my 3DS are tied to the system and not a virtual ID. If something happens to it, I'm pretty sure that there's no way to re-download without paying again. You would think that publishers would cut it out with these shady practices, seeing as though people on the web seem to expose them within seconds.

04596077bdbbd4327842d739accd8b0a
August 12, 2011

Actually, I think the Nintendo eShop is linked to your Club Nintendo ID, and on the Wii Shop you are able to re-download your purchase. But as with PSN's 5-download limit, these companies hold the power and content so they can easily remove the re-download privilege with any Terms of Service modification.

Pict0079-web
August 12, 2011

I'm still frightened of losing the Cave Story download on my DSi. I love that version of the game to death and I really don't want to lose my data.

Jon_ore
August 12, 2011

Opening a fresh, new video game is part of the reason I don't buy from Gamestop/EB unless as an absolute last resort. Ripping off the cellophane wrapper, knowing you're the first person to gaze on that copy of the disc and instruction manual, is a religious experience that music aficionados will also understand. At EB the cases are already open (and sometimes even nicked or scratched), the cellophane is absent, and the magic is gone.

Default_picture
August 12, 2011

The fresh smell when you open the brand new case is so irresistible. Sorry, I am a tad weird. Yes, I also dislike the digital-download fix. Although it is nice to purchase games without leaving the house, it lacks all the wonderful box-art that decorates your room on your shelf. On the plus side, I love the feature of installing your game on the hard drive--even if you own the actual disc. It prevents it from getting scratch or ruined.

Pict0079-web
August 12, 2011

I actually like taking the box art covers out of the boxes. I like to keep them around for future wall decoration. Me and my nerdy habits...

04596077bdbbd4327842d739accd8b0a
August 12, 2011

lol nerdier than stacking up DS games in bed? I think you're fine :]

Default_picture
August 14, 2011

Nice! Nothing wrong with that, although I stick with the posters. Not a bad idea Jonathan!

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.