Nintendo makes life difficult for its core fans

Photo-3
Sunday, August 21, 2011

Sometimes I feel like Nintendo treats its core North American fans like the U.S. Democratic Party treats its progressive base. Every now and then they’ll do something that kind of appeases their supporters, but for the most part they’d rather chase after the bulk of people who fall into the moderate or casual category. In short, I’m frustrated that Nintendo is being so stubborn when it comes to releasing a trio of solid Japanese role-playing games for the Wii in the U.S. It’s as if the company holds its hardcore fans to an unfair, high standard by expecting people to buy more games without actually putting out any that are worth buying.

First, Nintendo published Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story, and Pandora's Tower in Japan -- all of which earned fairly strong review scores. Then, they released Xenoblade in Europe last week and announced their intention to put out the other two titles sometime in 2012. But for some reason, the company doesn't seem too interested in bringing these experiences across the pond. North America has more Wii owners than any other region, but maybe not enough of them marked off that they enjoy JRPGs on those stupid surveys Nintendo is always asking its fans to fill out.

 
Back in late June, the company struck a blow to the hopes Operation Rainfall, an online grassroots campaign pushing for a U.S. release of those titles, as they thanked them for their enthusiasm but said they, "have no plans to bring these three games to the Americas at this time." Are the members of Operation Rainfall perhaps too passionate...or not passionate enough? More recently, Nintendo of America President Reggie Fils-Aime further confused everyone when he teased that they plan to watch "very closely" how Xenoblade does in Europe to decide “what to do with these titles.” Well, how rabid of a response do you want from your faithful fans before you decide to throw them a third-party bone?
 
I can’t even remember the last solid, non-casual game to come out for the Wii that actually caught my interest. Was it Metroid: Other M? That was almost a whole year ago!
 

But I suppose this highlights an interesting paradox: Nintendo doesn’t want to risk putting out games that appeal to the more niche, hardcore audiences if they won’t sell well, and dedicated gamers are less likely to buy those kinds of titles for the Wii because, if they're like me, they’ve already given up on the console for the greener pastures of the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3. But that’s kind of bullshit.

I like good games of all genres and platforms, so if Nintendo had some dope JRPGs, I’d pick them up. Just like if the Democrats actually did something that benefited people who have to work for a living, I’d probably vote for them. In the mean time, until either group acts to appease its base, I’ll just remain apathetic and reluctant to self-identify as a supporter. It just sucks being left with the short end of the stick, or in this case, Wii remote.
 
Problem? Report this post
ALEJANDRO QUAN-MADRID'S SPONSOR
Comments (25)
Jayhenningsen
August 21, 2011

I wasn't even aware of Xenoblade Chronicles, but now that I've read up on it, it sounds like a solid addition to the Wii's library. I'm sad that I may never see this game in North America.

Photo-3
August 21, 2011

Yeah, I'm excited to play it and hoping that Nintendo gets its act together and puts it out here.

Default_picture
August 21, 2011
I never understood Nintendo's habit of crushing the hopes of its fans. On the plus side, at least we MIGHT see Operation Rainfall in North America. As long as Reggie quits messing with my head...
Photo-3
August 21, 2011

You talking about Mother 3? Sigh....

Default_picture
August 21, 2011

I still really have issues with Nintendo about that one. The story was far better than any other Mother game. And yet they held back. That was one of the few RPG stories that actually made me cry! Dammit...

Photo-3
August 21, 2011

I have a Japanese cart. of Mother 3, but I haven't bothered to play through with a translation. I know those guys did a patch for the ROM, but for some reason it doesn't play very well on my Mac which makes rhythm-based combos difficult. 

Default_picture
August 22, 2011
What's funny is that I didn't figure out the rhythm-based attack system until I saw a video of it. I can see how a Mac can make things difficult. The slowdown is a nuisance to deal with.
Ragnaavatar2
August 21, 2011

I was never a fan of the Wii, but with all the price cuts it's had and the promise of these titles in American territory, I was very willing to buy a console just to play these three RPG masterpieces. But with Nintendo's recent "screw hardocores" attitude, I doubt that's going to happen.

The saddest part of it is that, by the time Nintendo decides to bring them to America (if ever), everyone who wanted to play them would have either imported or pirated them.

Photo-3
August 21, 2011

Well, hopefully if people enjoy them enough to import or pirate, they'd support an official launch as well. The small glimmer of hope is that the Wii U is suppose to be backwards compatible, so it's not like Nintendo is going to entirely jump ship when they launch their next console.

Default_picture
August 21, 2011

I'd take it a step further: How about Nintendo invests in original IPs? (in the North American market, anyway.)

I'm sick of the endless franchise updates. More than anything else, this behavior is indicative of Nintendo's ultra-conservative approach to game design. I want fresh, original ideas, not Metroid 17. And yes, I realize I'm probably pissing in the dark on this one.

Lolface
August 21, 2011

Actually, I agree with you Jason. Growing up with a Sega Genesis, I have zero nostalgic attachment to any of Nintendo's franchises, so I don't need to play another Legend of Zelda game starring another elf in a green tunic coincidentally named Link who is trying to save Princess Zelda, the thirteenth of her name, from a guy who was destined to be evil when his parents named him Gannondorf.

Then again, what was Nintendo's last original IP? Was it Pokemon? That was almost 15 years ago.

Photo-3
August 21, 2011

I don't know for sure what their last original IP was, but maybe Pikmin back in the early 2000s? Possibly NIntendogs in like 2004?

30028_10150166634715182_701805181_12295430_2588182_n
August 21, 2011

I'm really disappointed in Nintendo and with every decision they only dig a deeper hole. It is almost as though they don't understand their fans. They feed us what they think we want. It's been a long time I ever wanted to play a game as much as Xenoblade. I think this is how euro fans usually are treated, ever since back in the SNES days. They usually got the bad end of the stick. I guess now we get a bit of that taste. Honestly I don't understand Nintendo's reasoning for this slap in the face to fans. 

Sexy_beast
August 21, 2011

I'd take that a step further, Jason: You're pissing into the wind...of a typhoon.

If you think Nintendo makes life difficult for its core fans, Alejandro, imagine the trouble a prior fan has. Nintendo provides some great quality with their products that is still unmatched to this day, but they suck at...well, pretty much what Jason pointed out; they do almost nothing new.

The company has become so predictable and monotonous that one would have to be legally insane to actually prefer them over anything else.

Default_picture
August 21, 2011

Nintendo took risks in the NES and SNES days...their corporate attitude was the epitome of the intransigent Japanese corporation, but there was an incredible variety of fresh IPs. I can't fault the big "N" for catering to the casual crowd; but I can't support them, either.

Photo-3
August 21, 2011

well put.

Default_picture
August 21, 2011

I've jailbroken (homebrew channeled) my Wii just so I can play Xenoblade Chronicles, which I've ordered from the UK. But I'm not happy about this, or the lack of good Wii games period. I'm not really enthused about the Wii U at all after being bitten by the Gamecube and then the Wii, and this is just rubbing salt in it.

Photo-3
August 21, 2011

Yeah, man, I feel the same way. For some reason, I never considered un-regionally locking my Wii just to play a retail imported version. 

Default_picture
August 21, 2011
Someone needs to usurp the Nintendo throne and set things straight over there
Robsavillo
August 22, 2011

The real unspoken bullshit that everyone's dancing around is that Nintendo decided to stick with region-locking. Sony's PS3 is the only home console that doesn't enforce region-locking for games, which is how I was able to slip the Asian-region release of Demon's Souls into my American PS3 without a hitch (this was before word of the North American release).

But there are ways to play Japanese Wii games on an American Wii: See Joystiq's step-by-step process (for these games specifically).

Nintendo is still committed to region-locking with the 3DS. If you value imported games, I suggest not patronizing companies who engage in these anti-competitive practices.

Photo-3
August 22, 2011

wow, that's a really neat tutorial. There's something fun about importing games, but I totally agree that the best option is to not support companies that region-lock their consoles. 

Default_picture
August 22, 2011
Neat. I suppose I should feel guilty if I were to do this. Supposedly, anyways.
Waahhninja
August 31, 2011

If this were any other site I would have come back to this article after reading it the first time and found a million politically charged messages with sniping back and forth across parties. As this is Bitmob, the entire conversation stayed on topic. Very impressive.

The fact that Nintendo has fallen to the dark side of "Easy Casual Gamer Cash" instead of supporting the core gamers who stayed with them for 20 years has truly saddened me.

Default_picture
August 31, 2011

Bitmob is largely troll-free. Can't say the same about any of the "mainstream" gaming sites (we all know who they are).

Default_picture
April 19, 2012

come on..............people need to give noa and noe a break

 

they have never done more rpgs than this gen

 

They believe in rpgs

 

fire emblem is getting localized............thats enough

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.