Spotlight: the Great Debate Edition

Default_picture
Saturday, February 20, 2010

This edition of the Community Spotlight focuses on some of gaming's (and game journalism's) greatest debates.

Jon Porter starts off with perhaps the only debate more widely discussed than "games as Art": Can games successfully imitate film? Jon doesn't seem to think it's necessary. Jeffery Sandlin is next with his top five points on how to effectively write about games.

Richard Moss examines the supposed rivalry between Uncharted and Tomb Raider. Is one franchise ultimately superior to the other, or could they both stand to learn something?

Finally, Taro Russell addresses the issue of single-player vs. multiplayer, and how he feels story is more important than online gaming.


Why Comparing Games to Movies Does Everyone a Disservice
By Jon Porter
Jon breaks his long silence on Bitmob to comment on the games vs. movies debate. He's tired of it, and feels the different mediums are largely incompatible as far as comparison is concerned. To Jon, games shouldn't try to emulate film. This doesn't bode well for Heavy Rain....

 

Mi: Top 5: the Most Important Top 5 Ever
By Jeffery Sandlin
I don't think I've ever seen Jeffery use as many exclamation points as he does in this piece. Of course it isn't him writing, is it? The mysterious Mi offers up its five points on how writing about games needs to improve. This post leaves me with an unsettling feeling of too much cheer.


What Tomb Raider Could Learn from Uncharted (and Vice Versa)
By Richard Moss
On the surface, Uncharted and Tomb Raider appear to be filling the same niche and accomplishing many of the same goals, but a deeper analysis reveals their stark differences. Richard breaks down the elements that both franchises do well, and what they could learn from the other. I say we need a crazy crossover game where Nathan Drake and Lara Croft are after the same, likely world-altering and dangerous, treasure.


Loner Gaming
By Taro Russell
Multiplayer gaming just isn't Taro's thing. While many people cracked open their copies of Modern Warfare 2 and promptly hopped online, Taro had a single-player experience in mind. Is it wrong to appreciate the story of a game over shooting dudes in a deathmatch? Whatever you believe, Taro has at least one ally in me.

 
Problem? Report this post
JASMINE MALEFICENT REA'S SPONSOR
Comments (3)
Assassin_shot_edited_small_cropped
February 20, 2010
I'd totally play that Tomb Raider/Uncharted crossover game;D
Lance_darnell
February 20, 2010
Jeffrey's Mii posts are just awesome. I highly recommend checking them out!
Redeye
February 20, 2010
Heh. That's one I in Mi for the record Lance. Also for the record Mi is a girl. I'm looking into something to make her character more defined in the future. For now thanks a metric ton for the spotlight Jasmine. The Mi posts desperately needed the exposure.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.