Super Mario 3D Land Review

Default_picture
Monday, November 14, 2011

I’m going to get this out the way and say that I’m not a Super Mario Bros fan.  In fact, I only like Mario when he’s racing, partying, playing tennis, or saving the day in some kind of 3D environment that doesn’t limit him to jumping from left to right.  Something about the slight slipperiness in platformers has always frustrated me to the point of generally avoiding them unless I only have a few minutes to spare.

With that being said, I love Super Mario 3D Land.  The game successfully takes franchise staples and pushes them from 2D to 3D.  In fact, the very first thing I did when I started playing was push the circle pad up, causing Mario to run into the background.  “Yes!” I thought to myself.  I could now run around enemies instead of having to jump on or over them.

The second thing I noticed is the lack of slipperiness when running around.  Mario moves slower and is definitely less agile in 3D Land, however it never feels cumbersome or out place.  SMB vets can still sprint through levels if the game feels too slow or easy for them.

Additional features such as the Propeller Box, Boomerang suit, and the return of the Tanooki suit all fit in nicely with the environments.

The game’s 8 main worlds are mixed up and genuinely fun to navigate. 

You’re no longer just moving from left to right, but also heading up, down, closer,farther, all while utilizing the different suits. 

A few floor tile-based puzzles may slow you down, but they’re not so difficult that you have to stop and stare for a while to figure out.  Occasional mini-boss battles also change-up the gameplay a bit.

While the relatively linear levels are all on the short side, they still contain enough shortcuts, alternate routes, and bonus items littered throughout to warrant additional play-throughs.

You still bump into winter and desert themed levels, but they’re sprinkled throughout the worlds as opposed to being isolated to one.  You’ll never have to make your way through 6 consecutive deserts to progress in the game.  Additional bonus levels are in every world, that can be unlocked from collection star coins, of which there are 3 hidden per level.

Super Mario 3D Land’s environments are a blast to play through, but the game still has some shortcomings.

The game just might be too easy.  I’m terrible at platformers, but I was able to collect all the star coins on the first 8 worlds and beat the game in one 6 hour sitting.  At one point, I had 88 lives in stock.  After beating the game and unlocking the “Special World” counterparts, it took me about another 8 hours to finish those off while collecting every single star coin.

I’m perfectly okay with 14 hours of gameplay, but I wouldn’t be surprised if Mario veterans shaved hours off my game time.  The game throws out so many lives and upgrades you may never see a single “Game Over” screen.  After beating the game I decided to go on a suicide spree just to see what would happen when I ran out.  You’re taken to a “Game Over” screen, and brought back to the World Map with four lives.  The only thing really lost after running out of lives is your mid-level checkpoint.

The rare portions of the game I found difficult suffered from camera issues.  The camera sometimes feels too close to Mario.  This, coupled with the 3DS’ small screen, made some of parts of the game feel too congested.  Jumping from falling platforms, avoiding traps and projectiles, all while being chased by a doppelganger is enough to have to worry about.  The last thing you need is to not be able to see Mario or the next platform you have to jump on.

I found the game’s 3D features didn’t help much either.  The 3D didn’t change my habit of using a character’s shadow to track distance.  You could play through the whole game with the 3D slider off and still do fine.

The game’s lack of difficulty and few camera issues aren’t bad enough to frustrate or bore you away from coming back for more.

Super Mario 3D Land’s collectibles, short and sweet levels, and above all else, classic platforming gameplay make it a worthy addition to any 3DS owner’s collection.

 
Problem? Report this post
DANNY CONCEPCION'S SPONSOR
Comments (4)
Cucco-obsessed-link
November 14, 2011

Interesting perspective!  Most people love most all of the Mario games unconditionally (except for Super Mario Sunshine), so it's refreshing to see the opinion of a gamer who doesn't have that standpoint.

100media_imag0065
November 18, 2011

Great read. I am glad you enjoyed it. I know many non-Mario lovers and I just can't seem to convince them of Mario's brilliance!!

I enjoyed the game for sure, but the fact that I beat it (with every Star Coin in ever level) in under 3 hours was a huge, huge bummer. I knew Nintendo was going to do this. I knew they were rushing this out the door with a limited budget in order to get a Mario game for the 3DS out before the Holidays. I knew they were rushing it. I just knew it, and I was right.

It took me over a dozen hours to beat Super Mario Galaxy and about the same to beat Super Mario Galaxy 2. Super Mario 3D Land is $20 more than Super Mario Galaxy is at this moment, and I beat Super Mario 3D Land in a quarter of the time it took me to beat Super Mario Galaxy. It is disgusting really. ESPECIALLY since Nintendo is making all this fuss lately about making sure their customers feel like they got a complete product when they buy a Nintendo game.

Well Nintendo, I did not get a complete product here. I got about 25% of the product. I got a Mario game that recycled levels over and over again, recycled music, enemies, power-ups, and 90% of the assets from Super Mario Galaxy. Instead of a full product, I got a Mario game that can be completed in 3 hours, with all star coins. Oh, but once you beat the game you can play through it all over again with the star coins in different places!!! No thanks Nintendo.

What makes me even angirer about this is how so mnay reviewers just "forgot" to tell its readers that this Mario game was severely low on content. Not a single one of the reviews I read told me that I was going to pay $40 for a 3 hour Mario Game. Gameinformers own review listed the replayability as "Moderately High", which is a lie. A big fat lie.

Default_picture
November 18, 2011

That's definitely my biggest gripe about the game.  I thought I went through the game quickly, and I suck at platformers.  3 hours?  Wow.

I gave the game a positive review because I believe it's among the best original 3DS titles yet.  The best of.... all 3 of them.

100media_imag0065
November 18, 2011

You're right. It is by far the best game on the 3DS, and for the 3 hours it lasts, it is an amazing Mario game. I am just totally bitter about the length. Nintendo should be ashamed. Just because it is a 3DS game, does not mean it should not have the same attention to quality and length that a console Mario game would have.

I believe they figured they can get away with it because people would just be happy to have a new Mario game, and they were right, since most reviews completely glossed over the fact that it is about a quarter as long as any console Mario game. Even Super Mario Land is much longer.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.