Separator

Musings of a Gamer: Fanboyism and Gamers

100_0005
Sunday, October 11, 2009

Editor's note: You think gaming fanboys are bad? Try covering pro sports -- NASCAR fans are absolutely out of their minds when it comes to the reasons why they love their drivers and hate the rest. Mike's got little patience for this sort of blind loyalty -- and the coarse conversation that comes along with it. Is he a hater, or just someone who wants rational discourse? -Jason


Bitmob is a wonderful place. For the most part, we contributors can give our honest opinions and expect to have a respectful dialogue without ridiculous name-calling and insults to our intelligence. This is the reason that this is the only site I've ever had the desire to share my thoughts on.

While I was thinking about this, I realized that fanboys/girls are the exact reason why I would never dream of posting elsewhere.

Fanboys aren't exclusive to the realms of videogames. Sports teams, celebrities, and musicians all have their fanatical followings. When I was a kid, girls were insane over the Backstreet Boys or Leonardo DiCaprio, and I verbally sparred with them. It was in good fun, and I tolerated their obsession. Today, however, my patience with fanboys is extremely low.

 


He is rather dreamy, I suppose....

Gamers in particular have a lot of emotional investment in their games and the makers of their hardware. Scrolling boards at other game-info outlets shows that hundreds of people are content with slamming fellow gamers for their opinions. I have a Nintendo Wii and a PS3, but I can't remember ever slamming Microsoft or their products simply because I don't own them. I wouldn't even mind a discussion about the pros and cons of their respective systems, but it's not an easy thing to do.

The language people use in their fanboyish rants is also unsettling. I'm still unsure whether it's the anonymity of the Internet or the immaturity of somebody who doesn't have much life experience, but you never hear real speakers end every word with "asshole" or a sexual slur. I'd never take them seriously if they did. Obviously, if you like the Yankees and I like the Red Sox, we're going to be competitors, and most people are going to get insulting and personal.

But I think gamers should be especially wary of the image they send out. We all know that gamers come from all walks of life, have different body types, genders, financial situations, or social status. The popular perception of gamers, however, is still the dark basement with a large man eating Cheetos and playing the newest MMO. I think this gives us a responsibility to our hobby to project a better image. Sports, music, and movies are already established mainstream mediums in our country, and gaming does not have the wiggle room that these entertainments enjoy.

So gamers, am I just a hater, or do you agree that fanboys/fangirls are a detriment to the gaming community? Is it immaturity, or something else? As always, please post your thoughts and engage in some civilized discussion with me.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (13)
Default_picture
October 10, 2009
Confession: Sometimes, during my morning coffee, I go over to 1up.com just to read the latest flamewar. It's my new funny pages. I love it when a simple company announcement turns into a BATTLE FOR ALL YOU BELIEVE IN.
Lance_darnell
October 11, 2009
@Tommy - From what I am reading you want more fanboy fights? I can do that! Just you wait... ;)
100_0005
October 11, 2009
I too can be mildly entertained by outrageous message board posts....but half the time I don't even understand what they're yelling about
Default_picture
October 11, 2009
@Lance- Oh, no. There are PLENTY of flamewars out there(on other sites) to keep me entertained. @Mike- that's my favorite part. A good deal of the time THEY don't know what they are yelling about.....
Default_picture
October 17, 2009
[quote]fanboys/girls are the exact reason I would never dream of posting elsewhere. [/quote] Same here. I have respect for other gaming related sites, but I often wonder why it is I even bother to scroll down after the article has ended, knowing full well there is only negativity there.
Default_picture
October 28, 2009
When I was younger I was a Sega fan boy. Well, Sega has dropped the ball, and I am now a Bitmob fanboy.
Default_picture
October 28, 2009
The most recent whiteboard over on 1up was about this, and it made the excellent point that your level of love for any give thing isn't what makes you a fanboy, it's your intense hatred of the competition. This is the mentality I can't figure out.
Default_picture
October 28, 2009
This is why I hardly post on Kotaku any more, or bother to read the comments. Not to bag on them particularly because I still like the top-level posts and think they have decent content. But they do stand out in my mind especially as a site that used to be really good and had fairly decent comment threads until they got popular enough that all the rabid PS3 and Xbox 360 morons migrated over there and infest every thread (apparently the Wii people are not fired up enough). I'm not sure you can avoid it without a lot more moderation than Kotaku's willing to put into it, because they will find you.
Bhhdicon_copy
October 28, 2009
Fanboys. I remember the same thing as Joshua Garcia up there, I knew people with only a Genesis that would bag on the SNES. But especially, during the N64 and Playstation battle (the Saturn was never popular amongst the people I knew), I'd try so hard to keep a cool head whenever someone would flame me (in real life!) for only having that N64. That's when I made it a point to get every single system, from then on so that I could avoid the fire and have valid points for any conversation in the future. I've stopped posting on the 1up boards almost entirely too; the intelligence level there is collectively only as high as a three year old's (on average).
Default_picture
October 28, 2009
Remember the old Sega ads where Sega pretty much spit in the face of every Nintendo owner and Nintendo's reply was to "Play it Loud"? Ah, those were the days... Actually, console war advertising would be a lot more interesting if Sony, M$, and Nintendo started clawing at eachother's faces. Then you'd really see some fanboy violence... But yeah, fanboys suck. It should be about the games, not what console they're on.
Shoe_headshot_-_square
October 28, 2009
Clearly you're an idiot. You're a waste of Bitmob space! Nah, just kidding, of course. Just didn't want you thinking we're too cool around these here parts.
October 28, 2009
1. I hate being the 13th comment. It's Halloween, for Christ's sake! 2. I'm really disappointed by the fact that your graph does not include one of the most noteworthy parts of the fanboy anatomy: the mouth stained with Totino's pizza sauce. 3. I, in all seriousness, believe the opposite; I think fanboys are a [i]good[/i] thing for gaming. Sure, I hate fanboyism, but I believe it's an energy that helps power the industry and general interest in gaming.
100_0005
October 28, 2009
@ Tony: I don't disagree that enthusiasm definitely pushes the gaming business to new extremes, but I kind of think that you can have enthusiasm without resorting to ridicule and screaming matches @Hsu: Nobody was thinking YOU were too cool ;) @Victor: I suppose the idea is that most folks can't play every game, so like the whiteboard on 1up says, they feel duty-bound to defend their choice to the death! But I agree, I'm a fan of specific games, and I don't much care about where they come from as long as I can play them.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.