The Curse of Old-Man Hands: Fact or Fiction?

Default_picture
Sunday, May 24, 2009

I touched on this lightly in my debut Bitmob post, but with retro remakes and reboots all the rage these days, I felt a certain subject needed to be addressed in its own blog entry. It's something pretty much every older gamer experiences, but we tend to sweep it under the rug and pretend it doesn't exist. But it's OK -- we shouldn't deny this virility-robbing condition. So let's talk about...the terrifying curse of old-man hands.

First, let's give credit where it's due. I first heard the term bandied about by Bitmob overlord Dan "Shoe" Hsu back in his EGM editor-in-chief days. Every time Shoe reviewed...well, pretty much every game that required quick-twitch muscle fibers and wasn't Mario Party, he'd blame his underachieving performances on his "old-man hands." The implication was clear: "I could kick your ass, young intern Brooksie, if only I were 10 years younger." As a thirtysomething gamer (but, just to clarify, still several years younger than Old Man Shoe!), those feelings resonate with me: I definitely feel like I've "lost a step," and the condition only worsens with each passing year.

 

Punch-Out!! on Wii's the perfect example. Even though my mind knows that Von Kaiser goes into a slight pause before rearing back to deliver a punishing uppercut, my hands don't process this information in time -- and I get a series of terrifying Teutonic fists to the face as a result. I sorta feel like that wily thirtysomething southpaw who's lost his fastball. Sure, he knows more about the game of baseball than ever. But his body's betrayed him, and now he has to make do with guts and guile (or, in some cases, sandpaper and spitballs).

It wasn't always this way. I could beat the original Contra without using the Konami Code. I could beat any Mega Man game without any difficulty at all. And I could definitely beat Mike Tyson. But modern reboots Contra 4 and Mega Man 9 frustrated me to no end -- I didn't remember the original NES versions being so tough! And while I've had more success with Punch-Out!! on Wii than those two games, I definitely feel like I'm getting by more on smarts than actual finger speed.

But in a recent Twitter update, former 1UP news editor and newly hired Current.com online producer Philip Kollar seemed to throw a wrench in the "old-man hands" theory. Young Philip, a strapping lad of just 23, seems an unlikely candidate for slowed reflexes, yet he opined that Punch-Out!! made him feel wizened. So perhaps these old-school rehashes really are more difficult than the NES classics. After all, a good friend and I decided to break out the NES and tackle Battletoads again a couple of years ago, and we got as far as we ever did back in the day. So perhaps, as games have gotten easier over the years, we simply haven't been tested as much as we were back in the '80s and '90s, so we've all lost our fastballs...whether we're in our early 20s or early 40s.

What do you think? Are developers of these retro reboots artificially inflating the difficulty, thinking we'll simply chalk it up to aging hands and slowed reflexes? Or is there some truth to the matter that these games aren't any harder than the old NES games? Have we really slowed that much in the last 15 to 20 years?

In the meantime, I wanna feel young for a bit, so I'm taking a break from Punch-Out!! and starting up the perfect remedy: a deliberate, plodding Japanese RPG in Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Summoner 2 -- Raidou Kuzunoha vs. King Abaddon (boy, that's a mouthful, Atlus). More about that one later, though.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (17)
Lance_darnell
May 25, 2009
Great Blog! I believe that we have not been tested much in the last 20 years. Once games started being made for the console first, instead of for an arcade and then ported, they were no longer made so difficult because they did not have to be quarter-suckers. Yet, I have used the "old-man hands" excuse a number of times....
Shoe_headshot_-_square
May 25, 2009
I feel it is due to age. I've noticed this affliction from playing one specific game for over a decade now: Tetris Attack. I [b]know[/b] I'm not as good at it as I used to be. Moving the blocks isn't as instinctively lightning quick as it was 10 years ago, so I know my skills have deteriorated. Of course, I don't play as frequently, either, so it could just be Tetris Attack-specific reflex atrophy. Michael Donahoe just IMed me earlier today, telling me about how frustrating it was dealing with Sandman in Punch-Out!!, to where his hands were all sweaty and shaking. Makes me not want to play it any further (I'm on Soda Popinski) and enjoy my evening instead with some simple gardening: [url]http://bitmob.com/index.php/mobfeed/I-Cant-Believe-Im-Gardening.html[/url]. :)
Default_picture
May 25, 2009
I think it's that the new retro games are harder than the originals. I just beat Mega Man 2 for the first time in my life not twenty minutes ago, and I had very little trouble with it. When I was a kid, I couldn't even get past Quickman or Heatman's stages. I only died once on my way to Wily's castle. Stupid falling crabs.
Default_picture
May 25, 2009
Great article Fitch! I loved the reference to baseball. Greg Maddox might have more control over the plate late in his career, but he definitely lost the inside fastball.
Default_picture
May 25, 2009
I thought everyone knew about "old man hands"? I know I realized I was afflicted when I replayed Chrono Trigger on the DS. What wasn't even an afterthought on the SNES version became very frustrating on the DS. What am I talking about? That stupid Simon Says game where you have to get the Crono clone. It's gotten to the point that I'm not hoping for a Vagrant Story DS if only so I can relish my fond memories of chain combos that were executed with, dare I say, the greatest of ease.
Default_picture
May 25, 2009
Are there any older pro gamers? That dude from King of Kong is still breaking records isn't he? I guess that doesn't disprove "old man hands", but those guys seem to be getting on alright. Personally I don't think I've gotten any worse in general, it's more of a function of how much I play a game now vs. how much I used to play it. Especially twitch games like Punch Out(!!). For me it's more being in the zone than a physical handicap. I am only 26 though.
Default_picture
May 25, 2009
I can relate to the Punch-Out!! comments. I just spent an hour earlier this evening trying to defeat Mr. Sandman on Title Defense mode. He's got the fastest attacks of anyone in the game, and his "wink-punch" attacks were giving me fits. He winks (and shows you which fist is coming) for a split second, nay, a [i]fraction[/i] of a second, before delivering an uppercut that's as close to an insta-punch as anything in the game. Even though my eyes and brain knew what to look for, my hands had trouble reacting - or worse, freaked out [i]of their own accord[/i], and dodged into the punch. I was finally able to [i]barely[/i] eke out a win, but I certainly haven't been made to feel my age by a video game in quite some time.
Twitpic
May 25, 2009
I definitely think it is both things, old man hands and developers making things easier. [quote]That dude from King of Kong is still breaking records isn't he?[/quote] Although that is true, the guy plays [i]nothing but[/i] Donkey Kong.
Default_picture
May 25, 2009
Lol I am so scared of this happening to me. Thanks for bringing it up Fitchmeister.
Greg_ford
May 25, 2009
Ha, Fitchmeister! I love this piece. I wonder if the nightly news will pick up on it and start considering it a real medical problem, like how Nintendo thumb was all the rage back in the '80s?
Default_picture
May 25, 2009
I honestly think it has more to do with time than it does with phalange-atrophe (a term I've newly-coined as of this writing and which I expect no one to perpetuate). Back in the 80's and 90's I had one thing in my life to worry about: School. Yeah, I shoulda been worried about my notable lack of dating success, but why bother with such things when there was Ghouls N' Ghosts to bash into submission?
Lance_darnell
May 25, 2009
[b]OLD MAN HANDS[/b] [img]http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3093/3096251788_8b0417f61c.jpg[/img] [b]Causes[/b]: Prolonged exposure to the natural radiation of the sun. [b]Symptoms[/b]: A decrease in videogame scores. [b]Cures[/b]: Cyber-neurological implants - [url]http://search.barnesandnoble.com/Last-Flesh/Christopher-Dewdney/e/9780006384724[/url]
Default_picture
May 26, 2009
Make sure to wear your Mario Party gloves at all times, Shoe! [img]http://www.elecplay.com/features/E3/screens/nintendoglove.jpg[/img]
Default_picture
May 26, 2009
This fear is equaled to that of getting Carpal Tunnel in my mind. I've noticed myself slowing down a bit. I now fear the "press X as fast as you can" mini-games that pop up every now and then. For me it's not the quickness that's a problem, it's the endurance.
Default_picture
May 26, 2009
Games are getting easier, every game seems to be made trying to get you to replay with achievements or trophies as incentives. I've xompleted more games in the last 5 years than I ever had before (I'm 33). I know for a fact I'm not getting any better so they must be getting easier
Default_picture
May 26, 2009
I doubt this is true. Games don't require the same skills as playing professional sports. It's true that older people react slower, but I've never tried to use that kind of argument with videogames. It's just really sad for me to read that at age 50 I will enjoy videogames less than now, and don't see why it should be.
Default_picture
May 26, 2009
I missed out on the Mega Man games back in the day, so I didn't get to experience their legendary difficulty, but I managed to beat Mega Man 9 in a few hours without much difficulty. I also managed to get most of the way through R-Type I & II with R-Type dimensions, even though I'd barely played any shmups before. I'm in my twenties, so I may not be experiencing the "old man hands" you guys are talking about, but I don't think these reboots are any harder than the old games. I decided to play Mega Man 2 for the first time immediately after playing 9, and I thought it was a bit more difficult, due to the final boss.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.