Separator
I May Game, But I Ain't No Geek
Default_picture
Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Editor's note: Brian doesn't like labels -- when they're applied to him or to other people. He thinks it's time to drop the stereotypes. I've been called a number of stereotypes -- from sports guy to game nerd. Do these labels bother you? -Jason


Over the past few years, I've noticed a disturbing trend in video game publications -- the interchangeability of the terms "geek" and "gamer." It's not that I have anything against geeks or people who refer to themselves as such -- it's just that I've never thought of myself as one. I prefer to be judged on an individual basis rather than being lumped into some kind of stereotype that includes a broad spectrum of individuals.

Being referred to as a geek isn't the only term I'm offended by -- I also don't want to be known as a jock, a nerd, a goth, and the countless other stereotypes that exist. You may think that I'm a hypocrite since I sometimes refer to myself as a gamer, but I see that term in a different light.

Unlike the other terms I mentioned, video games don't encompass my entire life. I often refer to myself as a gamer on video game websites to let people know that I'm not someone who only plays the latest Madden.

 

So why am I offended by being called a geek? Well, let's look at Dictionary.com's first definition: "Geek: a peculiar or otherwise dislikable person, esp. one who is perceived to be overly intellectual." I believe that this simple definition doesn't describe me, because I consider myself to be unique, and I certainly don't think of myself as peculiar.

My interests may be strange to some people, but I've never found anything wrong with them. I don't see anything wrong with being interested in a creative, interactive medium like video games. I also don't see why it's strange for me to like music that moves me -- whether it be Nobuo Uematsu pieces or songs from a rap artist like Trae. And lastly, I don't find my interest in history peculiar. Some people may believe that examining the past is useless, but I believe that we can learn something from it.

These three interests obviously don't comprise my entire life, but my point is that I have yet to list something that is peculiar. Playing an interactive video game is no stranger than throwing a round ball through a hoop or running around in circles on a track.

Also, I'd like to point out that I've never been referred to as a "geek" in person, but I've been stereotyped. When I was younger, someone referred to me as a "momma's boy," but that quickly changed after I beat my entire class in an arm-wrestling competition.

After I'd grown into an adult, some people thought I was a thug because of my shaved head and style of dress, but once again, they misjudged me. People have also assumed that I'm a college basketball player or another type of athlete based on my appearance, when in reality, I usually pick up a basketball two times a year.

Even online I still get stereotyped -- but in different ways. Oftentimes, when I mention liking a particular role-playing game, I'm referred to as a "Japanophile" or someone that hates American games. Supposedly, this is because I'm playing what these posters call "gay" games. And apparently, liking a game like Tales of Symphonia completely clouds my judgment and leaves no room for liking a Western title such as Mass Effect or God of War 2. Oh, and because I play RPGs, I must be a weak, trench coat-wearing nerd who likes to cosplay.

My point is that these kinds of stereotypes are ridiculous. In no way do they define me, and I don't think they're a good descriptor of other people, either. I believe that the same goes for the term "geek." I can sort of understand why some people would use that term, because it can also mean someone that is deeply interested in something, but I believe that it's selling people short.

I'm sure some video game journalists and regular Bitmob contributors may refer to themselves as such, but I don't think that's what they truly are. Nothing about the people working at Bitmob has made me think they're weird -- I just think they're people that are passionate about something. They're actually living their life, unlike people who just follow what society dictates to them.

If someone plays Dungeons & Dragons, what's wrong with that? I've never played the game myself, but I don't see how that's any less respectable than someone who plays a game of pick-up basketball with their friends at the YMCA. Also, I don't think being a programmer magically morphs someone into some kind of freak. I have a deep amount of respect for people who develop the variety of applications we use these days, and the video games we play during our spare time. I also see no problem playing a video game set in a fantasy world. So what if the characters are kids or are androgynous -- does that mean I'm a sideshow just for playing the game?

By now, I hope you've gotten the gist of what I'm trying to say. I'm not trying to hate on people who refer to themselves as geeks -- I'm just saying that game enthusiasts such as ourselves are far more complex than the terms we're typically defined by. We're also more complex than our physical appearance, and we have more to offer than the video games we play.

Let's stop selling ourselves short and embrace our individuality.

 
0
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (19)
Twitpic
September 29, 2009
Brian, again, great stuff! I completely agree. I wear glasses, and more often than not people think I'm smart and can fix stuff, i.e. computers.

Occasionally I'll pretend I know what I'm doing, just to mess with 'em. ;D

;D;D
Twitpic
September 29, 2009
Oops, don't know how three faces appeared...weird.
Darkeavy
September 29, 2009
The problem Brian, is that the term "geek" means different things for everyone. I consider a geek a hip gamer who thinks a Space Invaders shower curtain is cool.

For me, a "nerd" is the social outcast stereotype. Probably because I was called a nerd in early grade school. So that name is tainted for me.

Sterotypes are simple-minded people's way to automatically "know" someone. So I'm being a little hypocritical. Because I do stereotype people as geeks. But that is the stereotype in my mind I want to hang out with.

Hey great article Brian! Clear and concise, and it got me thinking.
Dsc00669
September 29, 2009
Great read!

The thing is the term geek, especially recently, is being portrayed in a more positive connotation. I wear my geek badge with pride!
Default_picture
September 29, 2009
I think the term 'geek' - in England at least - has changed so much in the last couple of years. Now, everyone who enjoys and invests in anything describes themselves as a geek. I'm a bit of a music geek, I'm a proper football geek, car geek etc.

A while back, the notion of a football geek would have been an oxymoron. It's all different now.

Maybe it has something to do with the internet and the validation of every niche culture. I'm not sure. Either way, for us, the term geek has found widespread acceptance.

Oh, and D&D;!? Seriously? You f**king GEEK!
Default_picture
September 29, 2009
I know what you mean. Yea there are plenty of stereotypes out there as you pointed out and yes it bugs you, but do you really think it's hindering you. Why would you want to converse with those people anyways?

Btw I've played D&D; and it's awesome. 'Course that kinda depends on who you're playing with.
Default_picture
September 29, 2009
If you think only what appears in a dictionary is what defines a word, then you have much larger problems than being called a "geek".
Brett_new_profile
September 30, 2009
Geek, nerd, dork -- they're all just shorthand to me. I know who I am, so what other people call me doesn't bother me.

That said, thanks for saying you don't think I'm weird. :)
Default_picture
September 30, 2009
@Cosmo- Thanks. Ah...tricking people is fun isn't it?

@Conner- Thanks. Agreed, words like "geek" mean different things to different people. I think we all stereotype people now and then. I know I do it sometimes and usually regret it later.

@Davin- Thanks. I've actually been wondering about that. It seems like quite a few people have heard the term "geek" used in a positive way these days. But apparently my community is stuck in the stone age or something.

@Lee- I hear ya. I guess like you and some other people on here are pointing out, "geek" is used in a positive context in some places. Unfortunately, I've never heard the term used that way where I live, but that doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

@Marco- I don't think it's necessarily hindering me--it just annoys me a little. I just think people who have video games as one of their major hobbies get stereotyped a lot, and wish it would occur less.
Default_picture
September 30, 2009
@Chris- I'm not saying that dictionary is my Bible, but that particular definition is still used in many situations. Online, I've heard "geek" used in a positive context, but I've never heard that in person, so it isn't like that definition is completely irrelevant.

@Brett- Haha no problem. But yeah, I suppose knowing who we are as people is more important than the terms people use to describe us.
Normal_f3c8726ca7d523c031f09eb7d4e54430
September 30, 2009
You bring up several good points Brian. Nice article.
Default_picture
September 30, 2009
Great article. Man, the front page has been a Shirkathon (tm) lately. And yes, that's trademarked.;D
Default_picture
September 30, 2009
@David-I agree. Geek and Nerd are no longer labels meaning Screech from saved by the bell. With the advent of technology like iPods and Facebook hitting the mainstream, "Geek" and "Nerd" are no longer negative terms.

@Brain Shirk-If it bothers you when you are called a geek, it is because YOU are still subscribing to the old label and connotations the terms used to have.
Jason_wilson
September 30, 2009
I prefer yutz, myself.
Default_picture
September 30, 2009
Great article Brian, the way so many people need to label others as being one thing or another really bugs me too. All through my school years I was the receiver of much unfair 'labeling'. I ignored it for the most part, shrugging it off simply as idiots being idiots, it did get to me now and then though.

Its pretty uncommon these days but I do occasionally meet people who as soon as I say 'I play games' look at me like I'm a freak. Thank god most of them are old and will die soon. lol

Steriotypes do often make good comedy material so I like them when they're used in that sense but being defined as one single narrow minded thing by others who don't understand you is just a lazy way of thinking imo.

My mother still thinks I'm a nerd and this is a women who obsesses over Star Trek, haha.
Default_picture
September 30, 2009
Well said, Just like the Breakfast Club 8)
Lance_darnell
September 30, 2009
I am called "crazy" all the time, but considering what passes for "normal" nowadays, I take it as a compliment!

Way to go on the front page Brian! Perhaps short and sweet is the way to go? ;)
Default_picture
September 30, 2009
"Much ado about nothing," should be the Bitmob tagline. Lately there's been a lot of TL;DR where people make a big deal out of stupid insignificant things.

Surely Bitmob is not a community of whiny crybabies?
Brett_new_profile
September 30, 2009
@Alain: People are writing about topics that interest them, whether they be large or small. I encourage you to write about something that's significant to you.
You must log in to post a comment. Please register or Connect with Facebook if you do not have an account yet.