Separator
Online Game Racism Is Getting Worse
Default_picture
Monday, October 26, 2009

Editor's note: Tony's a bit disheartened over all the racism he's finding online, but he points out a bigger problem: its infectiousness. Why can't white and black (and Bitmob green) play nice together? -Shoe


I’m a white guy. A white guy who grew up in a town that had KKK rallies in the Gazebo and had David Duke speak at the local library when he was a kid.

I grew up embarrassed of my town and like to think the era I grew up in was filled with more racism than present day. I say this because of my confidence in society and its way of educating the public over time. A society that has learned and can learn from its mistakes.

Yes, I know that there is and always will be racism in our society, but as an adult, I’ve felt good about feeling that it’s getting better. Hell, we’ve voted in our first black president, right?

 

In the past few years, I’ve been drawn back into gaming and found myself refreshed to the vast capabilities it has to offer. Games are still games, but they’ve molded into something different: its own social network.

Hours of my life are now taken through the cable wires and modems around the world, linking me together with hundreds of thousands of other players. I was amazed -- not only to take part in this first hand but at the unbelievable amount of ignorant racism strewn throughout these very same wires and modems.

First off, let me just say that I am in no way advocating a ban against online gaming. I love it and have had more positive experiences than anything else. But the fact is, when it’s not positive, it’s turned its ugly head at me in a way that’s hard to forget, long after the green light on my 360 has turned gray. Let me also say, I think Major Nelson’s acknowledgement and forthrightness in taking on this subject matter is great.

My surprise may come from my overconfidence in today’s modernizing world, along with whom I tend to surround myself with in my life. I simply don’t see racism often. It’s possible I’m living in a bubble, but yet, I refuse to completely believe that. If I see a fight or an argument in life, there’s no link to degrading someone’s race or dropping the N-bomb in normal conversation as an insult.

Yet, I was recently invited to a party in a Gears of War 2 game, only to immediately be asked by the team members if I was black. I left the match, but something stuck with me afterward.

They weren’t hiding the racism.

I’ve never experienced this before in any other aspect of my life. I mentioned earlier that we had just elected our first black president -- but could this have lit the fire? Is this the straw that broke the backs of all of the closet bigots in our scope? It’s as though they’re uniting within certain aspects of my game activity. A whole team of racists in a room on a random multiplayer game just seems out of whack.

This is a system that’s supposed to check all of these troublesome issues at log in, so anyone can meet and have an enjoyable time together -- a way to unite people into one common thread we all have: We love to play. Also, we can’t “see” anybody in live matches (aside from a few camera exceptions with games like Uno) which astonished me even more when I saw the prevailing ignorant insults.

Uno

Instead, I’m finding more and more that racist slang is becoming common and I worry. I worry because, yes, there are young kids that look up to adult players and may listen to this jargon. I also worry it’s contagious. It’s opening up a new pot to the masses that might not know the true meaning behind such racist terms.

The history surrounding these metaphors and beliefs are filled with a hatred many don’t understand. Let’s say li'l Johnny is called to the dinner table after a heated online match and throws out an N-bomb to his brother like it’s no big deal. Who do you think is going to get the blame? Yes, gamers, Microsoft, Sony...but not the actual culprit. The culprit has moved on to infect others.

I don’t pose to have an answer here on how to fix this. I simply want to offer up an acknowledgement of this beast's increasing activity. Of course, I know race is an overwhelming issue in our society as well, but it’s supposed to be getting better isn’t it?

It’s not supposed to find new outlets to breed itself into a larger more hateful monster than it already is. I know how impossible it is to filter this out over a live connection, considering how many people are integrated together at any given moment.

And let me say this again, now that you’ve heard my rant: I love online play. I’m just feeling a bit disappointed and disheartened in a community whom I feel so close to can have such a rotten element, sidled with some of the best times I’ve had in the last few years. Or maybe I’m just naïve.

 
1
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (31)
Default_picture
October 17, 2009
I haven't been online all that much lately, but I know exactly what you mean. I think the people saying racist things right are cowards who'd never say that stuff publicly. I'm sure they're also the same people talking shit about Mexican and black people on youtube. If you go to any rap video (even obscure underground stuff), you'll find several morons only clicking it so they can make racist comments.

I grew up in an area with quite a few racists too, but many of them took it underground. On the surface, it appears like a very liberal area, but only people who've lived there long enough know the ugly truth.

Anyway, it's a shame all that happens online. My little brother started playing Halo 2 online at age 9 or 10 and I worried about him hearing that garbage, but at least he was smart enough to see how stupid the people making those comments were.

Nice article.
Default_picture
October 18, 2009
Tony, from what I can see from your article that you're saying it's a bunch of white people throwing N-bombs and that's true. However, you fail to mention that blacks, Hispanics, and Asians do the exact same thing to each other and to whites as well. I've been called a cracka, honkey, white bread, and other names that can be equally hurtful.

Racism is racism. It's not only white people saying racist things. It's time to call out others of ALL races for their hurtful speech as well.
Default_picture
October 18, 2009
I completely agree with you Jeremy. But I'm speaking just from my personal experience in the story. I also feel that the N-Bomb is one of the harshest terms that seems to be thrown around casually in some instances.
I feel that word specifically, has deep roots.
Jason_wilson
October 18, 2009
I've never encountered this playing online on my PC. While this is a very small sample, it seems like this is a console issue.
Default_picture
October 18, 2009
Jason, I'm speaking directly from a console perspective. So, yeah, in my case you're right on.
Brett_new_profile
October 18, 2009
This is why I typically play online with everyone muted. It really is getting out of hand.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
I think it's a mistake to confuse what kids do and say online with actual racism. They're not the same thing. I'm an Italian Jew married to a Korean woman, and we live in Georgia. After living here for roughly 25 years, I've seen my share of real racism. Kids spouting out racist slurs on the Internet while gaming is something else. I'm not excusing it, and I'm not saying it isn't possibly indicative of a deeper problem, but it's something else, I believe. Racism is and always has been a hate born from fear of others not of your race. I don't get that (in most cases) from the crap I read while gaming. Most of it seems like kids simply running amok -- the equivalent of kids going crazy when the teacher leaves the room.
Img_0183
October 26, 2009
I'm fortunate to have not encountered much racist language while playing online - but instead I've encountered significantly more homophobic language. However, I don't own a Xbox 360, and most of the online multi-player I've participated in has been in TF2 games and on servers which I've come to feel comfortable and safe on.

This is, by the way, one of the reasons why I'm not too happy with Modern Warfare 2 eschewing dedicated servers - because I like being able to find a safe server and to stick to it in the long term.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
Personally I hate racism because it is plain lazy and illogical. If you dislike someone, dislike them for traits like being stupid, or smelling bad. Tony D I have disagree with you on the N Word being the worst. They are all equally bad. I been called a couple things for being Irish. It sucks in general because if they got to know me they would find PLENTY of things to dislike. I sing off key, and can't do any other dance besides, the Robot, River dance, and the awkward "Does this look cool" dance, I give friends hugs, and in the mornings I have coffee breath, and I am about as close to girlie without liking men as a straight guy can get. See PLENTY of things to not to like.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
I don't go too hard on games. Racism is everywhere but it is just more visible in games because people can hide behind a gamertag/username. If your co-workers or classmates could do the same you would be surprised what comes out of their mouth. As long as rappers and other successful people use the "N-Word" (That term is such a cop out) it will be used by the average joe.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
Pretty much ever since party chat, I've always played in a party. It's a shame because I do feel that there were games in which either productive team communication was helpful or genuinely entertaining and non-hateful conversation was taking place.

We even tried for awhile not being in party chat (at least for the start of a game), but it's not worth digging through a menu at the start of or during each game nine times out of ten (or more) due to hateful, generally annoying, or lack of communication.
100_0005
October 26, 2009
Tony, I've noticed this very thing. I don't usually play co-op games online, but I do play competitive games like Soul Calibur 4. Every time I get a victory, I brace myself for the slew of racial slurs or the sexual stuff (f*g and gay are the newest catch words of the new generation). I often mute the television at this point because all i'm there for is to play the game. I think the anonymity is really a big cause for it, since they don't have to face down someone when they say those things. It's really a shame
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
@Alexander - I was about to say the same thing. The level of gay bashing in online game chat is very scary.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
@Mike, I haven't seen it much in co op either. Usually co op playing tends to lean on more of a team aspect. Players are on the same side and the gameplay is not as competitive.

In the multiplayer (competitive matches) I see the most heated slang spread. That's why I pose the question on if players even realize the meaning of what they are saying.
Or are they just repeating this hatred from the last lobby room matching area.

Default_picture
October 26, 2009
Nice article. I always mute other players so that I don't have to risk hearing a slew of racist, sexist, and homophobic remarks while I play online.

However at the same time I'm always unsettled by the idea that these people I'm having a great time playing with could be revealed to be huge bigots if I chose to unmute them.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
Kids can be incredibly cruel. Especially when they don't know anything about you.

People still call me an Al-Queda terrorist. >:(

And I am Puerto Rican! :o
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
I agree. Most of my adult friends and I quit playing Halo because of how mad all the dipshits made us feel. I think alot of the time its stupid kids and now we pretty much only game together. I use to hear kids trying to be funny for their friends. They would have voice coming over the T.V. I use to take advantage of this by yelling for their mother to come in so she could hear the kids being nasty. It actually worked a few times. How do I know? They suddenly quit the game when someone came into the room to see what all the noise was. We all make jokes. Right or wrong but don't go overboard and be an asshole!
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
@Mike Gingras: "f*g and gay are the newest catch words of the new generation"

Kids have been saying that for a long time.

@Tony DaSilva: Nice article. This is one of the things I like about Bitmob, it's not a constant storm of corporate PR masquerading as news.

I honestly can't tell if racism is getting worse online. I think some people are card caring members of the KKK, some think saying it makes them cool, and some don't know any better. It doesn't justify any of it though.

It would really, really be nice for example, if that report abuse function on XBL actually did something beside get gay people banned for saying they're gay in their profile.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
I hear ya!

Language becomes abhorrent when people are playing on-line. You really do have to ask why parents would let their children get away speaking like that - and worse still, if it's the adults throwing these stupid remarks around you don't have to wonder why non-gamers would find it hard to take gaming community seriously.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
I think anonymity allows people to sink a little bit lower online than they would in public. I also think that a lot of games, like Gears of War, are an opportunity for people to revert to base behavior; it is a game where you get to bathe in the blood of your enemies after all. Hopefully all this will start to change, but in the meantime, I just leave any game that has been overtaken by racist talk. Life is too short and there are too many other games (and players) out there.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
It was racism and adolescent junk talking that made quit Halo 3. In all honesty I understand how big of a chunk the 6-17 year old gaming market is, but I really want to see an Xbox Live 18+ credit card verification system.

It sounds very harsh, but it's mainly the teenage demographic that uses most of the racial slurs and nonsense insults. I think that would definitely cut back a bit on it, but asides that people will still do it because of the anonymous online. If anything to improve a beefed up reporting system would do wonders.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
i play COD on PSN and i do the same thing every time a game starts...mute everyone. that way i don't have to listen to the bullshit that people spout. i just wish i could mute people in the lobby before a game starts.
Default_picture
October 26, 2009
I'm sick of this as well. Microsoft needs to embrace their own gamer rating system and tout it as a primary feature of Live, make it something you can't ignore.

Make it heavily encourage that you rate everyone you meet. Don't force it, because that will cause bogus ratings, but make it so whenever I quit out of a game, it prompts me to rate who I was just playing with. Cache a ten second clip of what their last voice chat was so I can help identify them. Give everyone weekly summaries of their rating so they can see why it's going down or that it's going up.

Tony's right, it's never going to go away, but muting everyone as soon as you get into a game isn't a solution. If we really want this to change, we're going to have to wade through the shit in order to try and clean it up.
Me
October 26, 2009
The problem is that there will most likely never be any control over this short of being able to create a "kid" account and an "adult" account, everyone is going to be exposed to the human reaction.

The problem is anonymity. It's something that has been spoken about on many a forum and blog and seems to bring out the worst in most people. The internet is a melting pot of different creeds and belief systems and while 75% (probably more) of the people in this world believe racism and prejudices are wrong, that other 25% (really, just a made up number) don't. How do you censure that fourth of the world without bringing up a massive clusterfuck of additional problems? Even further beyond that, how can you tell who that 25% is when all they have to do is change their handle/xbox live tag/ psn id, etc?
Default_picture
October 27, 2009
@Mark T. Whitney

I don't think the problem is that the people who use the language talked about in this article are actually racist. I firmly believe the majority of people who behave that way do so for three reasons:

1) It makes them feel cool to do stuff they aren't supposed to (e.g. kids)
2) It pisses other people off and they get off on that (trolls)
3) Some of these words have become vernacular. I know of people who use the word 'fag' in place of 'friend'.

I don't think it's a matter of public perception of things like race and civil rights as much as it is then doing it just because they can.

Penny-Arcade nailed it with this comic: http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2009/8/17/

Gabe isn't homophobic, it's just become trendy. If we want it to stop, we have to stop it.
Img_0183
October 27, 2009
@John Shults - I agree entirely, and if PSN had a similar system, I'd definitely use it.
Default_picture
October 27, 2009
@ Jon Shults--I agree. I think while playing, some people bring forth their basest feelings and characteristics. Not that they might in personal contact, but rather their underlying thoughts are actualized and verbalized during play.

And @ Mark-- anonymity is the largest reason for their actions--indeed MOST peoples' actions on the internet in general.

Default_picture
October 27, 2009
I understand that "gay" and "fag" are thrown about online so casually that they've pretty much lost their original intention on calling out someone's orientation. I also understand that they're sometimes used to just try and make another gamer feel bad. "Oh no, I played so well and now someone thinks I'm gay. That's terrible and I shouldn't be so good anymore." Probably not word for word what they think they're trying to do but it boils down to it. You're trying to hurt someone's feelings any way that you can.

Problem is, it largely has no effect on civilized, intelligent people. Who it does affect is people like my friend Jason. He's an amazing player, good at everything and probably one of the best friends anyone could ask for. Before the xbox360 came along with party chat, I could never entice him to play Halo 2 (or anything competitive) online with my friends and I. Gay bashing. He's sick of it. I am now too, and it makes me wonder why it took having a gay best friend for me to fight back against those people or shut them out completely.

When someone calls a strategy I use gay, or me a fag for how well I did, I'll tell them they're right and ask what it says that I was that successful in the game. They usually shut up and leave the lobby. Am I gay? No. Am I encouraging the bashing of gay gamers? Hopefully not.
Default_picture
October 27, 2009
It's too bad there isn't a way to shame online racist players. Perhaps their avatar could be somehow visually marked so that everybody would immediately know that they're a racist jerk.
Me
October 27, 2009
@john While I agree with your three reasons, I think that racism is, in itself, a bit of a trend.

Definition of racism: a belief or doctrine that inherent differences among the various human races determine cultural or individual achievement, usually involving the idea that one's own race is superior and has the right to rule others.

racism in itself is a cultural thing and we are the ones who forward its progress but that is racism at its core. Whether someone does it because it's trendy, it's cool, or because it annoys others is irrelevant since those are core reasons a person is racist to begin with. Racism has always been a trend.

Let me ask you something in a bit of a screwed up way: during World War II there were many youth who signed up for the Nazi Army just to anger their parents and join along with their friends. They hated the Jews because it was part of the doctrine that their friends thought was righteous. Does this make them less of a racist than their friends and therefore their acts more forgivable?
Default_picture
October 27, 2009
@Mark T. Whitney

"Does this make them less of a racist than their friends and therefore their acts more forgivable?"

No, certainly not. I'm just saying that telling a 12 year old that "Gay people are people just like me and you and we shouldn't use the word 'fag' because it's offensive to them" isn't going to be as effective as a sizable chunk of the community committing to not tolerate the use of the word.

It's like how prominent the use of the word 'retarded' is. Despite my best efforts, I sometimes slip up and say retarded when I'm describing something I don't like. You can tell me all day long that people with mental disabilities are offended by that context and I will eat it up, because I know that's true. I don't wish to offend them. However, if I started getting social demerits or losing friends because of my use of the word, that would have a much more direct, and likely successful affect on me.
You must log in to post a comment. Please register or Connect with Facebook if you do not have an account yet.